Name of peer reviewer
*
First Name
Last Name
Email
*
example@example.com
Mobile number
*
-
Area Code
Phone Number
Your peer review reconsideration
1. Title of the submission reviewed
*
2. Date completed
-
Month
-
Day
Year
2 digit month, 2 digit day, 4 digit year
Date
3. Has the author revised the manuscript in a manner that makes it acceptable for publication?
Rows
Not Satisfied
Somewhat Satisfied
Satisfied
Very Satisfied
Incorporation of suggestions from your review
Originality and suitability for JoCAT readership
Content – relevance and interest, abstract, figures etc, conclusion, and referencing
Clarity and grammar
4. Your recommendation
Please Select
1. Accept with no revisions
2. Accept with minor revisions
3. Accept with moderate revisions
4. Accept with major revisions
5. Revise and resubmit
6. Reject
Please select your preference
5. Please explain your preference
6. What revisions are still needed?
Please provide clear constructive feedback and critique.
7. Upload any supporting files, for example, a tracked change version of the submission.
Browse Files
Drag and drop files here
Choose a file
Cancel
of
Thank you for carrying out this second peer review.
Should be Empty: