JoCAT Peer Review Complete Form

Name of peer reviewer

First NameLast Name

Email

example@example.com

Mobile number

Area CodePhone Number

Your peer review

1. Title of the submission reviewed

2. Date completed

Date

3. Was this submission adequately anonymised?

4. Originality and Suitability

Rows	Yes	No
Do you consider that this work is original?
Do you consider this to be of a suitable standard for publication in the Journal?
Do you consider this submission to be within the scope of the Journal?

Leave blank if not applicable. Add an explanation into your comments if you can't answer yes or no.

5. Content

Rows	Yes	No
Is the topic and content interesting, relevant and important to readers?
Does the abstract reflect and summarise the content well?
Are the images, figures or tables relevant to the content?
Does the conclusion support the content?
Are the references current and have they been cited correctly?

Leave blank if not applicable. Add an explanation into your comments if you can't answer yes or no.

6. Clarity and Grammar

Rows	Yes	No
Is it written clearly?
Is it well written?
Is the grammar, punctuation and syntax correct?
Is it an appropriate length? (see submission manual on website for recommended submission lengths)

Leave blank if not applicable. Add an explanation into your comments if you can't answer yes or no.

7. Your recommendation

Please select your preference

8. Please explain your preference

9. What revisions are needed?

Please provide clear constructive feedback and critique.

10. Upload any supporting files, for example, a tracked change version of the submission.

We accept files up to 15MB only. If the file is greater than that please use wetransfer to send the file. Thank you.

Thank you for carrying out this peer review – your support of our journal is greatly appreciated. We may need to contact you to reconsider the submission once it has been revised post-peer review.