• Image Annotation

  • Purpose:

    The survey will be used for my Bachelor project, "Seeing the Words". The project investigates the difference between art created by people against the art created by AI, which both use the same text prompt to depict an image. The art will be compared using image classification and analysis models. However, since analysing and classifying paintings is large and vague and can differ from person to person, this survey minimises the scope to a few attributes by collecting a consensus of labels from the survey participants. 

    The paintings used will be from the Renaissance era, relating to a text prompt from the bible. 

    Survey layout:

    This survey consists mainly of two parts:


    Part 1 (prompt analysis): The first part is analysing the given bible text, where we identify explicit objects and implicit objects from the text, such as elements, people, beings and any quantifiable entities that are referenced.


    Part 2(image annotation): In this section, five different paintings will be presented where you can verify the given annotation that might be relevant to the painting. for some subsections, you may also add a personal annotation that references entities in the painting.

    The survey aims to gather data on the elements incorporated in the painting and from the text. 

     This survey looks at the Binding of Isaac (Genesis 22:9-14).

    The result of the survey will be published in the near future and will be reused in the future for more following-up studies and comparisons of that of A.I.-generated art.

    PRIVACY:

    The survey will remain anonymous (a.k.a. you will not need to provide any personal data in the survey). Since this project is conducted as a part of my bachelor thesis, the raw data of the survey will not be published but will remain in the SURFDrive for backup for 10 years. You may provide your email address to get the research results. Your email address will NOT be associated with any data to be published but will only be used to update the research results.

     

  • Objects Text analysis

  • Text prompt (Binding of Isaac (Genesis 22:9-14))

    9 When they came to the place of which God had told him, Abraham built an altar there, and laid the wood in order, and bound Isaac his son, and laid him on the altar, upon the wood. 10 Then Abraham put forth his hand, and took the knife to slay his son. 11 But the angel of the Lord called to him from heaven, and said, “Abraham, Abraham!” And he said, “Here am I.” 12 He said, “Do not lay your hand on the lad or do anything to him; for now I know that you fear God, seeing you have not withheld your son, your only son, from me.” 13 And Abraham lifted up his eyes and looked, and behold, behind him was a ram, caught in a thicket by his horns; and Abraham went and took the ram, and offered it up as a burnt offering instead of his son. 14 So Abraham called the name of that place The Lord will provide; as it is said to this day, “On the mount of the Lord it shall be provided.”
  • Explicit referenced elements from the text (e.g "the pot was cooking" pot is explicitly referred)
    Rows
  • Implied elements from the text (e.g "the pot was cooking" Fire is implied since it is used for cooking a pot)
    Rows

  • Painting: Binding of Isaac(1598)

    Bartolomeo Cavarozzi(1587-1625) Media(oil painting on canvas)
  • Image field 63

  • People and Spiritual Beings

    This section only People
  • QA-3:Entities Present in the Picture
    Rows
  • Image field 64

  • Weather:

  • QB-1: What weather is best depicted in the image?
  • Image field 71

  • Animals:

  • QC-1:Which animals are present?
    Rows
  • Image field 80

  • Environment:

  • QD-1:environment elements present
    Rows
  • QD-2:Landscape present
    Rows
  • Image field 74

  • Other:

  • Painting 2: Binding of Isaac(1539)

    Lucas Gassel(1490–1568) Media (painting on wall)
  • Image field 115

  • People and Spiritual beings

  • QA-3:Entities Present in the Picture
    Rows
  • Image field 120

  • Weather:

  • QB-1: What weather is best depicted in the image?
  • Image field 130

  • Animals:

  • QC-1:Which animals are present?
    Rows
  • Image field 134

  • Environment:

  • QD-1:environment elements present
    Rows
  • QD-2:Landscape present
    Rows
  • Image field 139

  • Other:

  • Painting 3: Binding of Isaac(1598 - 1603)

    Carvaggio(1571–1610) Media (oil painting on canvas)
  • Image field 189

  • People and Spiritual Beings:

  • QA-3:Entities Present in the Picture
    Rows
  • Image field 194

  • Weather:

  • QB-1: What weather is best depicted in the image?
  • Image field 204

  • Animals:

  • QC-1:Which animals are present?
    Rows
  • Image field 208

  • Environment:

  • QD-1:environment elements present
    Rows
  • QD-2:Landscape present
    Rows
  • Image field 213

  • Other:

  • Painting 4: Binding of Isaac (1542-1544)

    Titiaan(1490-1576) Media (oil painting on canvas)
  • Image field 226

  • People and Spiritual Beings:

  • QA-3:Entities Present in the Picture
    Rows
  • Image field 231

  • Weather:

  • QB-1: What weather is best depicted in the image?
  • Image field 241

  • Animals:

  • QC-1:Which animals are present?
    Rows
  • Image field 245

  • Environment:

  • QD-1:environment elements present
    Rows
  • QD-2:Landscape present
    Rows
  • Image field 250

  • Other:

  • Painting 5: Binding of Isaac(1635)

    Rembrandt(1606–1669) Media(oil painting on canvas)
  • Image field 263

  • People and Spiritual Beings:

  • QA-3:Entities Present in the Picture
    Rows
  • Image field 268

  • Weather

  • QB-1: What weather is best depicted in the image?
  • Image field 278

  • Animals:

  • QC-1:Which animals are present?
    Rows
  • Image field 282

  • Environment:

  • QD-1:environment elements present
    Rows
  • QD-2:Landscape present
    Rows
  • Image field 287

  • Other:

  • Should be Empty: