2024 NOBCChE Technical Session Abstracts Logo
  • 2024 Technical Session Abstract Submission and Advancing Science Grant Application Form

  • Only enter the presenter's information if you are not the presenter.

  •  -
  • 0/150
  • Browse Files
    Cancelof
  • Browse Files
    Cancelof
  • Browse Files
    Cancelof
  • Abstract Evaluation

  • Abstract Review Rubric

    5-point Rating Scale:

    Excellent = 5; Very Good = 4; Good = 3; Satisfactory = 2; Needs Improvement = 1

    Total Max Scores:  Oral Abstract - 50           Poster Abstract - 30

    Criteria

    Description

    Total Max Score

    Quality of Written Abstract  

    (Poster/Oral Abstract)

    The quality of the written content is commendable and is free of multiple errors, such as: 

    • Grammatical +Typographical+ Punctuation
    • Conciseness/Clarity of research summary

    Max Score: 10

    (5 for each bullet)

    Demonstration of Scientific Problem

    (Poster/Oral Abstract)

    The abstract demonstrates the scientific problem and contains the required components: 

    • Hypothesis, objective, or statement of problem under investigation
    • Experimental methods/methodology used 
    • Results in summary form (even if preliminary)
    • Conclusion

     

    Max Score: 20


    (5 for each bullet)

    Research Topic & Interest/Significance 

    (Oral Abstract)

    The abstract topic is relevant to broader audience

    • Topic has broad appeal and has significant  impact/s on the scientific community/society
    • The significance of the work is clearly stated (is this a topic you will be eager to hear about?)

    Max Score: 10


    (5 for each bullet)

    Originality and Innovation 

    (Oral Abstract)

    The abstract demonstrates evidence of the following.
    • Novelty in research topic and approach 
    • Innovative approach to problem solving.

    Max Score: 10


    (5 for each bullet) 

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  • Additional Considerations

  • Oral Abstract Scores

  • Poster Abstract Scores

  • 0/500
  •  
  • Should be Empty: