Cake Order
To ensure your ice cream cake is crafted to perfection, we kindly request a 48-hour window. Need one sooner? Reach out directly to your nearest Ample Hills Creamery location for expedited options.
Select Cakes
*
prev
next
( X )
Cookie²
This cookie-centric cake includes half Chocolate Milk & Cookies ice cream and half Cookies & Cream ice cream with our Vanilla Sponge Cake, fudge, cone crunchies, whipped cream and more.
$
55
Small (6")
Large (10")
Quantity
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
S.S. Whitman
O Captain! My Captain! ice cream with Vanilla Sponge Cake, Caramel, cone crunchies, whipped cream, and rainbow sprinkles.
$
55
Small (6")
Large (10")
Quantity
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
The Jazmin
Banana Pudding ice cream with Vanilla Sponge Cake, caramel, cone crunchies, whipped cream, rainbow sprinkles and Nilla Wafers.
$
55
Small (6")
Large (10")
Quantity
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Custom Cake
All cakes start with our Vanilla Sponge Cake. Choose your own ice cream and toppings (subject to availability).
$
55
Small (6")
Large (10")
Quantity
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Once you've placed your order for the Cookie Squared, S.S. Whitman, or The Jazmin cake, you'll receive an instant confirmation. Opting for a custom cake? Expect a call from one of our store managers within 24 hours to finalize the details.
Custom Cake Ice Cream Flavor(s)
*
Flavor selections subject to shop availability. Call the shop to find out what's in stock!
Custom Cake Middle Layer
*
Please Select
Fudge
Caramel
Custom Cake Toppings
Chocolate Sprinkles
Rainbow Sprinkles
M&Ms
Cookie pieces
Whipped Cream
Back
Next
Cake Order
Please enter your personal information.
Your Name
*
First Name
Last Name
Email
*
example@example.com
Phone Number
*
Please enter a valid phone number.
Pickup Details
Let us know when you'd like your cake ready by! You're welcome to come pick up and pay for your order anytime the shop is open.
Pickup date
*
Pickup from
*
Please Select
Prospect Heights – 816 Washington Av
Prospect Heights – 623 Vanderbilt Av
Upper West Side – 526 Amsterdam Av
Astoria – 34-02 30th Ave
Select the shop closest to you. If you need delivery please specify that below (additional fee applies).
Pickup Date
/
Month
/
Day
Year
Please give us at least 48 hours to make your cake! Need it sooner? Call your nearest shop to discuss expedited orders.
Pickup time
Please Select
Afternoon (Open-5pm)
Evening (5pm-7pm)
Night (7pm-close)
Special Instructions (Optional)
Please verify that you are human
*
Place Order
Should be Empty: