2. Scoring Criteria
Applicants who meet the minimum eligibility criteria will be invited to complete Part Two of the Plus One ADU Application. In this stage, applications will be reviewed and scored based on project feasibility, cost, and the applicant’s written narrative responses.
Each scoring category includes defined benchmarks where points are either awarded in full or not awarded at all, with a total of up to 50 points possible. Projects that are shovel-ready at the time of submission will receive priority in the scoring process but will still be reviewed and ranked alongside all eligible applications.
a) Project Narrative (up to 20 Points)
Applicants will be asked to respond to four narrative questions, each worth up to 5 points, for a total of up to 20 points in this section. Each response has a 500-word maximum.
- Envisioned Project - Description (5 Points): Describe your proposed plan to construct or renovate an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) on your property.
- Envisioned Project - Intended Occupant (5 Points): Who do you plan to have occupy your ADU, and how does this align with your goals for the project?
- Specific Need - Financial and Personal Impact (5 Points): Explain how this grant and/or the anticipated supplemental rental income may help meet a financial or personal need. Include why this program represents your only viable opportunity to construct or renovate your ADU.
- Specific Need - Project Funding Plan (5 Points): Understanding that construction costs may exceed the $112,500 grant cap, describe how you plan to fund any remaining project costs beyond the grant amount.
b) Real Estate Tax Exemption Eligibility (5 Points)
Applicants may earn points if the property is eligible for a real estate tax exemption (e.g., RP-421-f for capital improvements to a 1- or 2-family home). Contact your municipality to confirm
c) Additional Affordability Commitment (10 Points)
Applicants who commit to renting the ADU to a tenant earning at or below 80% of HUD's Dutchess County AMI for the 10-year affordability period will receive full points.

2025 Dutchess County 80% AMI Limits established by HUD
d) Proximity to Public Transportation (5 Points)
Projects located within a reasonable walking distance to public transit (e.g., train, bus stop) are eligible for points.
e) Permitting Readiness (10 Points)
Projects that can move forward without requiring a zoning variance or lengthy municipal review (e.g., ADU is allowed by right or via site plan/special use permit) will be awarded points.
Note on Assets and Application Eligibility
Asset Income Calculations:
There are no asset (savings, retirement accounts, investments, etc.) limits attached to Hudson River Housing’s Plus One ADU Program. However, we are required to calculate the actual or estimated income that your assets may generate when determining household income eligibility. We use the current HUD passbook rate—6.1%—or the actual income generated from the asset, whichever is higher.
Example:
If your household of four has a gross annual income of $50,000 and $100,000 in checking, savings, or investment accounts:
If your assets produce only $2,000 annually, but HUD’s passbook rate would calculate $6,100 (6.1% of $100,000), Then we must add $6,100 to your income, making the total considered income $56,100. This applies regardless of whether the asset is currently producing income. Non-liquid assets such as vehicles or personal belongings are not included. If you plan to use part of your assets to pay for ADU costs beyond the grant award, that amount can be deducted from your asset total during eligibility review.
Requests for Additional Information:
Applicants are expected to respond promptly to any requests from Hudson River Housing for additional documentation. Failure to do so may result in your application being deemed ineligible.
Ineligible Applications: Applications will be denied if they do not meet eligibility requirements or if the home has conditions outside the scope of program support. This includes:
- Major pest infestations or environmental concerns
- Unresolved building or zoning violations
- Excessive debris or hoarding
- Lack of utilities or unsafe living conditions
If your application is not eligible for this program, Hudson River Housing may be able to refer you to other resources. Reach out to our team for more information.