VIII. Procedures for Reviewing and Managing Potential Conflicts of Interest
1. Review of Disclosures. The Governance and Ethics Committee collects and reviews Conflict of Interest disclosures, documents any Actual or Potential Conflicts of Interest, and determines any actions required to manage the Conflict of Interest.
2. Conflicts will be addressed as follows:
a. The Governance and Ethics Committee will review the information provided by the Affiliated Individual in their disclosure, requesting additional information from the Affiliated Individual if necessary to fully understand the nature of the conflict.
b. The Governance and Ethics Committee will determine whether an actual or apparent Conflict of Interest exists.
c. If the Governance and Ethics Committee, as applicable, determines that an actual or apparent Conflict of Interest exists, they will determine whether there are mitigating measures that can be implemented to alleviate the conflict and/or what steps the interested individual and/or USRowing must take or not take in order to avoid the conflict.
d. The disclosure of an Actual or Potential Conflict of Interest will not necessarily prohibit involvement in the disclosed activity or with USRowing. Rather, each disclosure will be reviewed individually, and actions may be recommended to protect the Affiliated Individual, USRowing, and the integrity of the decisions made by the Affiliated Individual and USRowing from actual, potential, and perceived conflicts of interests. These actions may include limitation of involvement, separation from certain USRowing activities, or requests to cease the activity in question.
e. All direction for managing conflicts will be discussed with the Affiliated Individual directly. If a material conflict is identified (whether actual or potential) for the CEO, Executive Director, board member, or Designated Committee (as defined by the USOPC Bylaws) member, the Governance and Ethics Committee must communicate, in writing, its direction on conflict management to the individual.
f. With Respect to Proposed USRowing Transactions or Business. In the event a Potential Conflict of Interest exists with respect to a proposed transaction or arrangement, then promptly and before any decision is made regarding the proposed transaction or arrangement, the Potential Conflict of Interest will be addressed as follows:
i. The interested person may make a presentation to the Governance and Ethics Committee, which may be convened telephonically, regarding the transaction or arrangement involving the Potential Conflict of Interest.
ii. The interested person will then recuse themselves from any and all discussion and approval (if applicable) of the Conflict of Interest.
iii. The Governance and Ethics Committee will determine whether an Actual or Apparent Conflict of Interest exists. For transactions, the Governance and Ethics Committee may consider whether a competitive bid or competitive evaluation exists.
iv. If the Governance and Ethics Committee determines that an Actual or Apparent Conflict of Interest exists, it will determine whether there are mitigating measures that can be implemented to alleviate the conflict and/or what steps the interested individual and/or USRowing must take or not take in order to avoid the conflict. The Governance and Ethics Committee may determine in some cases that USRowing cannot engage in the transaction or arrangement at all due to the conflict or Potential Conflict of Interest.
g. With Respect to Drafting Selection Procedures and Athlete/Team Discretionary Selection. The following more particularized disclosure requirements and procedures apply in the context of drafting selection procedures and athlete/team discretionary selection decisions in order to ensure that no Affiliated Individual participating in the process has a Conflict of Interest that will impact his/her ability to make a fair and unbiased decision in the athlete or team selection process. Any Affiliated Individual involved in the drafting of procedures, including the athlete representative, or on a discretionary selection committee who has a Potential Conflict of Interest must disclose it to the Governance and Ethics Committee for review. The following process will be followed:
i. The Interested Person may make a presentation to the Governance and Ethics Committee, which may be convened telephonically, regarding the Potential Conflict of Interest.
ii. The interested person will then recuse themselves from any and all discussion regarding the Potential Conflict of Interest.
iii. The Governance and Ethics Committee will determine whether an actual or apparent Conflict of Interest exists
iv. If the Governance and Ethics Committee determines that a Conflict of Interest is exists, it will either mandate the individual’s recusal from the process or determine to what extent, if any, that individual can participate in the process. The Governance and Ethics Committee may determine that the individual can still participate in the drafting of the procedures or be included in the discussions for discretionary selection of a team, but not take part in any sign-off, vote, or decision. For example, a national team coach or high performance director may provide information to the selection committee so long as such information is provided in a fair and unbiased manner and the committee member who disclosed the Conflict of Interest does not vote toward the final decision.
v. Under no circumstances will a person with an Actual or Potential Conflict attempt to unduly influence other members of the committee in the selection process.
If the Affiliated Individual is recused and a vacancy on the committee exists, either in the drafting process or on the discretionary selection committee, USRowing will use its best reasonable efforts to fill that vacancy. If a vacancy results in the athlete representative position, another athlete representative who meets the qualifications for that committee will be appointed and approved by a representative group of athletes.
h. With Respect to Seating Hearing Panels and Grievance Panels. The following more particularized disclosure requirements and procedures apply in the context of seating Hearing Panels and Grievance Panels in order to ensure that no Affiliated Individual participating in the process has a Conflict of Interest that will impact his/her ability to make a fair and unbiased decision in the hearing process to resolve a grievance.
Any Affiliated Individual appointed to a Hearing Panel or Grievance Panel, including the athlete representative, is obligated to disclose all Actual or Potential Conflicts of Interest prior to being appointed to a hearing panel. The Governance and Ethics Committee will solicit and review potential panel members’ disclosures and make a determination on whether they are a disinterested party for the matter under review.
Hearing Panel and Grievance Panel appointments are subject to an objection from either the complaining party or responding party on the grounds of a Conflict of Interest which is believed to be disqualifying.
Objections will be handled using the following process:
i. The objecting party may report the alleged Conflict of Interest to the Governance and Ethics Committee within seven (7) days following the parties’ notification of Hearing Panel or Grievance Panel appointment.
ii. The Ethics Committee will review the objecting party’s report and, taking all investigative steps necessary, determine whether an Actual or Potential Conflict of Interest exists.
iii. If the Governance and Ethics Committee determines that an Actual or Potential Conflict of Interest exists, the hearing panel member will be disqualified and a new hearing panel member will be appointed to replace the disqualified hearing panel member. The replacement hearing panel member shall be required to complete all disclosure requirements and is similarly subject to challenge by the parties as outlined in this section.
3. Reporting Violations of the Conflicts of Interest Policy. Any individual with a good faith belief that an Affiliated Individual has a Conflict of Interest may notify the Governance and Ethics Committee of such perceived conflict by emailing a report to the Governance and Ethics Committee at Chair.GovernanceandEthics@USRowing.org. Furthermore, should any Affiliated Individual become aware of any undisclosed Conflict of Interest, or any Conflict of Interest not fully disclosed, they should make full disclosure of their knowledge of the Potential Conflict of Interest involved by filing a report to the Governance and Ethics Committee at Chair.GovernanceandEthics@USRowing.org. Reports may be made anonymously, if desired.
All good faith reports of violations of this policy are protected under the provisions of the USRowing Whistleblower and Anti-Retaliation Policy. USRowing has zero tolerance for retaliation against an individual for filing a good faith report of a violation or potential violation. Consult the USRowing Whistleblower and Anti-Retaliation Policy for additional information.
4. Violations of the Conflicts of Interest Policy. If the Governance and Ethics Committee has reasonable cause to believe an Affiliated Individual has failed to disclose an actual or Potential Conflict of Interest, it will promptly inform the Affiliated Individual of the basis for such belief and afford the member an opportunity to explain the alleged failure to disclose.
If, after hearing the Affiliated Individual’s response and after making further investigation as warranted by the circumstances, the Governance and Ethics Committee determines the Affiliated Individual has failed to disclose the conflict or Potential Conflict of Interest, it will take appropriate disciplinary and corrective action. The Governance and Ethics Committee will communicate all such decisions in writing to the Affiliated Individual. The Governance and Ethics Committee’s decision will be final.
In the event that a member of the Governance and Ethics Committee is not disinterested in a particular alleged violation under review, that member shall recuse themselves from the investigation and decision-making process. In all cases, matters under review shall be reviewed by disinterested parties.
While any such failure to disclose a conflict or Potential Conflict of Interest is under investigation by the Governance and Ethics Committee, the Affiliated Individual will be precluded from engaging in further decisions of USRowing that bear any relation whatsoever to the matter that is the subject of the conflict or Potential Conflict of Interest.
5. USRowing Resources. USRowing’s Executive Director is responsible for this policy and its enforcement.
USRowing’s Executive Director can be contacted with any questions about this policy here conflicts@usrowing.org.
6. Additional Resources. Individuals who wish to report concerns related to this policy as it relates to involvement in the Olympic and Paralympic Movement, or are uncomfortable reporting a concern directly to USRowing, may also submit a report using the USOPC Integrity Portal. The Integrity Portal allows individuals to submit concerns to the USOPC confidentially and/or anonymously. Reports may be made online or by telephone.
Website: usopc.ethicspoint.com
Hotline: 877-404-9935
Team USA athletes may contact the Athlete Ombuds for independent and confidential advice on a variety of sport related matters, including their rights, applicable rules, policies or processes, and questions related to resolving disputes and grievances. The Athlete Ombuds can also help Team USA athletes connect with legal counsel or mental health resources if needed. All other USRowing athletes (i.e., athletes competing domestically at the masters or youth level, recreational athletes, foreign athletes), are welcome to visit the Athlete Ombuds website to review informational resources and should work directly with USRowing to understand additional resources and options available to them.
Email: ombudsman@usathlete.org
Website: usathlete.org