• Satisfy Your Craving!                  Eat the Cookie First

    Satisfy Your Craving! Eat the Cookie First

    Phone (315) 333-0283
  • Format: (000) 000-0000.
  • Date and time of pick-up: 48 hrs required for pick-up * Pick-up address: 6305 Stillmeadow Way, Williamson, NY 14589*
     - -
  • $20.00 Order Minimum: * All cookies are 3.5 oz before fillings and toppings are added *

    prevnext( X )
    The Cookie Monster . Meet The Cookie Monster: the ultimate treat for those who believe there’s no such thing as too many mixin’s. This beast is loaded with a crunchy demolition of crushed Oreos and Chips Ahoy chunks, then pushed over the edge with a triple chocolate delight of creamy milk chocolate, velvety white chocolate, and rich semi-sweet chips. It’s a cookie, filled with cookies, obsessed with chocolate.
    The Cookie Monster

    Meet The Cookie Monster: the ultimate treat for those who believe there’s no such thing as too many mixin’s. This beast is loaded with a crunchy demolition of crushed Oreos and Chips Ahoy chunks, then pushed over the edge with a triple chocolate delight of creamy milk chocolate, velvety white chocolate, and rich semi-sweet chips. It’s a cookie, filled with cookies, obsessed with chocolate.

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Peanut Butter Nutter. Our signature chewy peanut butter nutter surprise! Why choose one when you can have it all? We took a rich peanut butter dough and loaded it with extra peanut butter chips, semi-sweet chocolate chips and crunchy chunks of real Nutter Butter® cookies. To make it truly special, we topped it with a mini nutter butter bit and a thick Hershey bar. It’s the ultimate cookie-inside-a-cookie experience.
    Peanut Butter Nutter

    Our signature chewy peanut butter nutter surprise!    Why choose one when you can have it all? We took a rich peanut butter dough and loaded it with extra peanut butter chips, semi-sweet chocolate chips and crunchy chunks of real Nutter Butter® cookies. To make it truly special, we topped it with a mini nutter butter bit and a thick Hershey bar. It’s the ultimate cookie-inside-a-cookie experience.

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Fun Golden Oreo. Meet the Fun Golden Oreo:  It’s a nostalgic, vanilla-forward masterpiece that tastes like a birthday party in every bite. This soft and buttery cookie is bursting with a colorful explosion of Funfetti rainbow sprinkles and loaded with chunky bits of Golden OREO cookies. Inside, you'll find: Premium white chocolate chunks that melt into creamy, gooey pockets of sweetness and generous pieces of vanilla sandwich cookies folded directly into the dough for a satisfying textures. Each cookie is crowned with a full, classic Golden OREO for the ultimate "cookies-on-cookies" experience.
    Fun Golden Oreo

    Meet the Fun Golden Oreo:  It’s a nostalgic, vanilla-forward masterpiece that tastes like a birthday party in every bite. This soft and buttery cookie is bursting with a colorful explosion of Funfetti rainbow sprinkles and loaded with chunky bits of Golden OREO cookies. Inside, you'll find: Premium white chocolate chunks that melt into creamy, gooey pockets of sweetness and generous pieces of vanilla sandwich cookies folded directly into the dough for a satisfying textures.              Each cookie is crowned with a full, classic Golden OREO for the ultimate "cookies-on-cookies" experience.

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Fireside Favorite - S'more. The ultimate campfire-inspired indulgence that brings the great outdoors straight to your kitchen. For that authentic S'more experience, we've packed it with oversized pieces of milk chocolate and mini marshmallows that melt into silky pools throughout the dough. The finishing touch includes a perfectly roasted, caramelized marshmallow for that signature campfire char and a solid piece of a classic Hershey’s Milk Chocolate bar to tie it all together. It’s everything you love about a sticky, melty S’more—no fire pit required.
    Fireside Favorite - S'more

    The ultimate campfire-inspired indulgence that brings the great outdoors straight to your kitchen. For that authentic S'more experience, we've packed it with oversized pieces of milk chocolate and mini marshmallows that melt into silky pools throughout the dough. The finishing touch includes a perfectly roasted, caramelized marshmallow for that signature campfire char and a solid piece of a classic Hershey’s Milk Chocolate bar to tie it all together. It’s everything you love about a sticky, melty S’more—no fire pit required.

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Reese’s Peanut Butter ( Stuffed). Meet The Peanut Butter Cup Overload: a decadent, multi-layered tribute to the world’s most iconic flavor duo. This jumbo cookie starts with a rich dough packed with melty peanut butter chips and classic semi-sweet chocolate chips. The experience gets even better with: Molten Center: Stuffed with an entire Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup that turns into a gooey, creamy surprise in every bite. A Crunchy Crown: Topped with a colorful scattering of Reese’s Pieces Candy for that signature crunchy shell and extra peanut butter punch.
    Reese’s Peanut Butter ( Stuffed)

    Meet The Peanut Butter Cup Overload: a decadent, multi-layered tribute to the world’s most iconic flavor duo. This jumbo cookie starts with a rich dough packed with melty peanut butter chips and classic semi-sweet chocolate chips.  The experience gets even better with:  Molten Center: Stuffed with an entire Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup that turns into a gooey, creamy surprise in every bite. A Crunchy Crown: Topped with a colorful scattering of Reese’s Pieces Candy for that signature crunchy shell and extra peanut butter punch.

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Brown Butter Chocolate Chipper. Meet the Browned Butter Classic, an elevated take on the quintessential comfort treat. This cookie features a base of golden, nutty browned butter that adds a deep, toffee-like richness and an irresistible aroma. The delightful treat is generously packed with premium semi-sweet chocolate chips and hand-chopped chocolate chunks for a variety of melty textures. It’s sophisticated, chewy, and undeniably rich—the ultimate chocolate chip experience.
    Brown Butter Chocolate Chipper

    Meet the Browned Butter Classic, an elevated take on the quintessential comfort treat. This cookie features a base of golden, nutty browned butter that adds a deep, toffee-like richness and an irresistible aroma. The delightful treat is generously packed with premium semi-sweet chocolate chips and hand-chopped chocolate chunks for a variety of melty textures. It’s sophisticated, chewy, and undeniably rich—the ultimate chocolate chip experience.

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Cookies & Cream. Meet Cookies & Cream, the ultimate tribute to the world’s most iconic flavor duo. This cookie is a monochrome masterpiece, featuring a soft dough absolutely packed with chunky OREO cookie pieces and hand-chopped Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme bars for a double dose of crunch and cream. To take it over the top, it’s crowned with: Signature Crunch: A whole OREO sandwich cookie pressed right into the top. White Chocolate Bliss: Extra pieces of Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme for a melty, velvety finish. It’s a cookie, filled with cookies, topped with more cookies. Resistance is futile.
    Cookies & Cream

    Meet Cookies & Cream, the ultimate tribute to the world’s most iconic flavor duo. This cookie is a monochrome masterpiece, featuring a soft dough absolutely packed with chunky OREO cookie pieces and hand-chopped Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme bars for a double dose of crunch and cream. To take it over the top, it’s crowned with: Signature Crunch: A whole OREO sandwich cookie pressed right into the top. White Chocolate Bliss: Extra pieces of Hershey’s Cookies ‘n’ Creme for a melty, velvety finish. It’s a cookie, filled with cookies, topped with more cookies. Resistance is futile. 

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Chocolate Chipper Delight . Get ready for the best non-traditional chocolate chip cookie ever! It’s thick, soft, and full of melted milk and white chocolate in every bite. Perfect for birthdays, special occasions, or just a fun change!
    Chocolate Chipper Delight


    Get ready for the best non-traditional chocolate chip cookie ever! It’s thick, soft, and full of melted milk and white chocolate in every bite. Perfect for birthdays, special occasions, or just a fun change!

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Oatmeal - Chocolate Chip - M&M. The ultimate chewy, colorful comfort cookie. This hearty treat starts with a thick, toasted oatmeal base that’s loaded with a nostalgic blend of rich semi-sweet chocolate chips and iconic M&M's Milk Chocolate candies. To finish it off, we press an extra handful of vibrant M&M's right onto the top for a satisfying crunch in every single bite. It’s a perfect balance of wholesome oats and chocolatey candy bliss
    Oatmeal - Chocolate Chip - M&M

    The ultimate chewy, colorful comfort cookie. This hearty treat starts with a thick, toasted oatmeal base that’s loaded with a nostalgic blend of rich semi-sweet chocolate chips and iconic M&M's Milk Chocolate candies. To finish it off, we press an extra handful of vibrant M&M's right onto the top for a satisfying crunch in every single bite. It’s a perfect balance of wholesome oats and chocolatey candy bliss

    $5.00$5.00

    Item subtotal:$0.00$0.00
      
    Total
    $0.00$0.00

    Credit Card

  • Thank you for Choosing Simply Sweet! We Appreciate Your Business!

  • Should be Empty: