You can pay with a check, Venmo (once Andy tames it), Zelle (It seems like Zelle is offered by all banks in Naperville -- I don't know about credit unions) or a tax advantaged method including Qualified Charitable Distribution or a Donor Advised Fund.
Advantages of Zelle
1) You don't have to suffer with PayPal.
2) The chorus gets all your money rather than sharing it with Paypal