• It’s Time for the Plum Deluxe People's Choice Vote! 🎉🍵

  • We call it the People's Choice Vote – because your voice matters!

    Here’s the scoop: 

    • We've curated a list of past favorites – some were seasonal blends, some were Tea Club exclusives, and all were big hits in the PD community!
    • Now YOU get to vote for the teas you'd love to see return to our shelves permanently.
    • Voting is open to everyone! You don't have to purchase anything to cast your vote. 
    • To help you decide, we've created a special People's Choice Sampler Set featuring all the contender teas. (But remember, voting is open to everyone – trying them isn't required to participate!)
    • By the end of August, we’ll announce the winners. One or more of your top picks will be crowned the champions and become permanent additions to our shop!

    Voting is quick and easy – submit your vote below!

    We can't wait to see which teas rise to the top and become permanent fixtures in our shop, thanks to you. Voting will be open until the end of August.


  • You can only vote once, and you cannot change your vote after the fact - so proceed with care!  You can wait until the end of the month to vote - voting will close on August 31st at 9PM PT. 

  • Now, let's vote...

    We've curated a list of past favorites – some were seasonal blends, some were Tea Club exclusives, and all were big hits in the PD community! Now YOU get to vote for the teas you'd love to see return to our shelves permanently.

    We're so sorry if your favorite didn't make the list - this list is final.

    You may choose up to 2 teas.

  • Flavor Descriptions/Ingredients:

     

    Lemon Birthday Cake Herbal

    • Tastes Like: aromatic citrus, creamy cake, celebrating yourself
    • You might remember this tea from: newest addition to our herbal tea lineup
    • Ingredients: Green Rooibos, Lemon Peel, Raspberries, Blue Malva Flower, Vanilla Essence

    Spiced Date Walnut Cake Herbal

    • Tastes Like: date, pistachio, walnut, cake
    • You might remember this tea from: our 2025 Tea Lovers’ Advent Calendar Collection, a limited-edition flavor available through January 31st
    • Ingredients: Date Pieces, Green Rooibos Tea, Red Rooibos Tea, Orange Peel, Cinnamon, Cardamom, Ginger, Almond Pieces, Pistachio, Clove, Rose Petal, Safflower, Orange Blossom, Natural Flavor

    Mango Strawberry Black

    • Tastes Like: juicy magical mango, rich luscious strawberry, savoring sunshine
    • You might remember this tea from: featured in our April 2025 Tea Club (available April–June)
    • Ingredients: Black Tea, Hibiscus, Apple Pieces, Rose Hip, Strawberry Pieces, Raspberry Leaf, Calendula, Mango/Strawberry Essences

    Mango Strawberry Herbal

    • Tastes Like: juicy magical mango, rich luscious strawberry, savoring sunshine
    • You might remember this tea from: featured in our April 2025 Tea Club (available April–June)
    • Ingredients: Honeybush Tea, Hibiscus, Apple Pieces, Rose Hip, Strawberry Pieces, Raspberry Leaf, Calendula, Mango/Strawberry Essences

    Just Mango Black

    • Tastes Like: juicy old-fashioned mango, classic black tea, chatting with friends
    • You might remember this tea from: limited-edition flavor requested by our community for Customer Appreciation Month (August)
    • Ingredients: Black Tea, Mango Pieces, Calendula, Mango Essence

    Just Peach Black

    • Tastes Like: sweet peaches, soft vanilla, light wood, making memories
    • You might remember this tea from: featured limited-edition flavor during our last Customer Appreciation Month
    • Ingredients: Black Tea, Apple Pieces, Peach Pieces, Calendula, Peach Essence

    Peppermint Mocha Black

    • Tastes Like: rich chocolate, invigorating coffee, cafĂ© conversations
    • You might remember this tea from: our seasonal holiday tea, available November through the end of January
    • Ingredients: Black Tea, Peppermint, Cacao Nib, Coffee Beans, Chocolate Essence

    Hummingbird Black

    • Tastes Like: creamy banana, sweet pecans, ripe pineapple, taking it easy
    • You might remember this tea from: our discontinued/last-chance dessert tea inspired by Jamaican hummingbird cake
    • Ingredients: Black Tea, Honeybush Tea, Green Rooibos, Cinnamon, Pineapple Pieces, Apple Pieces, Cacao Nib, Safflower, Calendula, Vanilla/Banana/Chestnut/Pecan Essences

     

     

  • Cast Your Vote:*

  • One More... Optional Vote

    We're considering a swap.

     

    Eton Mess Black (Strawberry Meringue)

    • Tastes Like: crispy vanilla, fresh cut strawberry, moments of adventure
    • You might remember this tea from: our World of Tea UK sampler, brought back for dessert tea month 
    • Ingredients: Green Rooibos, Black Tea, Strawberries, Raspberry Pieces, Calendula, Blue Malva Flower, Jasmine Flower, Vanilla/Strawberry Essence
    VERSUS

    Strawberries & Cream Black

    • Tastes Like: jammy rose-kissed strawberry, creamy vanilla, deeper floral notes
    • You might remember this tea from: available in our year-round signature collection
    • Ingredients: Black Tea, Strawberry Pieces, Raspberry Leaf, Rose Petals, Strawberry/Vanilla Essences


    Strawberries & Cream Black has been a steady part of our signature collection, but Eton Mess brought such a fun burst of energy during the World of Tea UK sampler and dessert tea month that we're considering giving it a permanent spot in its place. The meringue-and-berry twist felt fresher and more playful than the classic rose pairing — curious to see if it holds up as an everyday favorite.

  • Since they're similar we can't feature both. Should we replace Strawberries and Cream w/Rose with Eton Mess?
  • Should be Empty: