• 📋 Sweets by Shay Pricing & Order Policies

  • 💳 BOOKING & PAYMENT POLICIES

    • A 50% non-refundable deposit is required to secure your order and pickup date.
    • Your order is NOT booked until availability is confirmed and the deposit is received.
    • Remaining balances are due 2 days before pickup.
    • Orders placed within 72 hours are considered rush orders and may require full payment.
    • Payment options: Zelle, Cash App, or approved card payment.

  • ⏰ ORDER TIMING & PICKUP

    • 2 weeks’ notice is preferred for custom orders.
    • Orders needed within 72 hours are considered rush orders and are subject to availability.
    • Pickup is in Milwaukee near 68th & Capitol.
    • The exact pickup address is provided once final payment has been received.
    • Please arrive at your confirmed pickup time. If you need to change your time, contact Sweets by Shay as soon as possible.

  • 🎂 CUSTOM CAKE PRICING

    Circle Cakes
    • 6” — starting at $130
    • 7” — starting at $135
    • 8” — starting at $150
    • 10” — starting at $170
    • 12” — starting at $220

    ❤️ Heart Cakes
    • 6” — starting at $135
    • 8” — starting at $155
    • 10” — starting at $190
    • 12” — starting at $240

    ✨ Other / Specialty Shapes
    • 6” — starting at $135
    • 8” — starting at $155
    • 10” — starting at $190
    • 12” — starting at $240

    🎂 Tiered Cakes
    • 4” + 6” — starting at $195
    • 6” + 8” — starting at $275
    • 8” + 10” — starting at $300

    Specialty flavors and detailed/custom designs may increase the final price. Final pricing is based on size, flavor, design, fillings, edible images, toppers, and other requested details.

  • 🧁 CUPCAKE PRICING

    Classic Cupcakes — $30/dozen
    Vanilla • Chocolate • Funfetti • Red Velvet • Lemon

    Specialty Cupcakes — $40/dozen
    Strawberry Cheesecake • Biscoff Cookie Butter • Oreo • Banana Pudding Cheesecake

    Cupcakes are sold by the dozen only.

    Custom designs, edible images, specialty decorations, fillings, and other add-ons may increase the final price.

  • 🍓 CUSTOM TREAT PRICING

    • Chocolate-Covered Strawberries
    • Rice Krispie Treats
    • Chocolate-Covered Oreos
    • Chocolate-Covered Pretzels
    • Cake Pops

    Minimum order is ½ dozen (6) per treat type.

    Pricing varies based on treat type, quantity, design, edible images, individual wrapping, and other custom details. A final quote will be provided after your order request is reviewed.

  • 🖼️ EDIBLE IMAGE PRINTING

     


    • Cake Images

    • Cupcake Images

    • Multiple Images on One Sheet

    • Custom Sizes / Shapes

     


    Pricing varies based on image size, quantity, layout, and any editing needed such as background removal, cropping, text, or custom sizing.


    Edible image orders are only confirmed once availability is confirmed and payment has been received.

    Please submit clear, high-quality images whenever possible for the best print results.

     

  • Should be Empty: