• Image field 60
  • Take pies off your to-do list — and give $10 back to Birmingham Falls PTO with every pie purchased! Enjoy immediately or store in your freezer for the upcoming Holidays! Pies will be distributed at school on Tuesday, November 17th between 4pm - 5pm in the Carpool Lane.

    All pies are 10" and serve 8-10. Check the box to the left of each item you'd like to purchase to add it to your cart. All preorders are due by end of day Wednesday, November 11, 2026.
  • Format: (000) 000-0000.
  • My Products*

    prevnext( X )
      Traditional Apple Pie. Locally grown and harvested apples, sprinkled with warm spices and baked to their peak of flavor inside our signature, all-butter crust.
      Traditional Apple Pie

      Locally grown and harvested apples, sprinkled with warm spices and baked to their peak of flavor inside our signature, all-butter crust.

      $37.50$37.50
        
      Signature Buttermilk Pie. This custard pie is baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg in our signature, all-butter crust. Very similar to a chess pie or crème brulee. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.
      Signature Buttermilk Pie

      This custard pie is baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg in our signature, all-butter crust. Very similar to a chess pie or crème brulee. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.

      $37.50$37.50
        
      Caramel Pecan Pie. Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine.
      Caramel Pecan Pie

      Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine.

      $37.50$37.50
        
      Cherry Pie. Bursting with sour cherries and full of flavor, our cherry pies are the perfect combination of both tart and sweet crowned with an old-fashion lattice, all butter crust.
      Cherry Pie

      Bursting with sour cherries and full of flavor, our cherry pies are the perfect combination of both tart and sweet crowned with an old-fashion lattice, all butter crust.

      $37.50$37.50
        
      Chocolate Chess Pie. A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell!
      Chocolate Chess Pie

      A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell!

      $37.50$37.50
        
      French Coconut Custard Pie. Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.
      French Coconut Custard Pie

      Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.

      $37.50$37.50
        
      Traditional Pumpkin Pie. A family’s traditional pumpkin pie, resonating with seasonal spices, in our all butter crust.
      Traditional Pumpkin Pie

      A family’s traditional pumpkin pie, resonating with seasonal spices, in our all butter crust. 

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Salted Caramel Dutch Apple Pie. A delicious twist on a classic, Dutch apple pie! Granny Smith apples are tossed by hand with warm spices, butter, and house-made caramel, then topped with our signature, brown sugar oat streusel. And then…. drizzled with ever more caramel and a light sprinkling of sea salt
      Salted Caramel Dutch Apple Pie

      A delicious twist on a classic, Dutch apple pie! Granny Smith apples are tossed by hand with warm spices, butter, and house-made caramel, then topped with our signature, brown sugar oat streusel. And then…. drizzled with ever more caramel and a light sprinkling of sea salt

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Salted Caramel Turtle Pie. Layers of rich salted caramel, silky chocolate, and South Georgia pecans, blended together in our signature, all-butter crust. This is a limited-run pie and one you won’t want to miss out on. If you love chocolate and pecans, you will fall in love with this pie.
      Salted Caramel Turtle Pie

      Layers of rich salted caramel, silky chocolate, and South Georgia pecans, blended together in our signature, all-butter crust. This is a limited-run pie and one you won’t want to miss out on. If you love chocolate and pecans, you will fall in love with this pie. 

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Chicken Pot Pie. Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!
      Chicken Pot Pie

      Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Chicken Ranchero Pie . Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!
      Chicken Ranchero Pie

      Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Pot Roast Pie. A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!
      Pot Roast Pie

      A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Southwestern Taco Pie. A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!
      Southwestern Taco Pie

      A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. Comes frozen and can be baked at your convenience with no defrost or prep time!

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Vegetable Pot Pie. Introducing our Vegetable Pot Pie – a medley of peas, carrots, red-skinned potatoes, and onions, seasoned to perfection. Enjoy a burst of garden-fresh goodness, mixed with a house-made roux, stuffed in a double all-butter crust.
      Vegetable Pot Pie

      Introducing our Vegetable Pot Pie – a medley of peas, carrots, red-skinned potatoes, and onions, seasoned to perfection. Enjoy a burst of garden-fresh goodness, mixed with a house-made roux, stuffed in a double all-butter crust.

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Quiche Lorraine. Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. Comes refrigerated.
      Quiche Lorraine

      Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. Comes refrigerated.

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Spinach Mushroom Quiche . Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. Comes refrigerated.
      Spinach Mushroom Quiche

      Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. Comes refrigerated.

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Tomato Pie. Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. Comes refrigerated.
      Tomato Pie

      Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. Comes refrigerated.

      $42.50$42.50
        
      Gluten Free Chocolate Product Image
      Gluten Free Chocolate
      $42.50$42.50
        
      Gluten Free Coconut Product Image
      Gluten Free Coconut
      $42.50$42.50
        
      Gluten Free Caramel Pecan Product Image
      Gluten Free Caramel Pecan
      $42.50$42.50
        
      Gluten Free Quiche Lorraine Product Image
      Gluten Free Quiche Lorraine
      $47.50$47.50
        
      Gluten Free Spinach Mushroom Quiche Product Image
      Gluten Free Spinach Mushroom Quiche
      $47.50$47.50
        
      Gluten Free Tomato
      $47.50$47.50
        
      Yeast Cinnamon Rolls. These rolls are lovingly made the old-fashioned way - with yeast and real butter, a single batch at a time. Light, doughy, and packed with brown sugar and cinnamon, these pillowy soft rolls are topped with silky icing to make them even more irresistible. Rolls are fully cooked. Thaw on counter for 1 hour or overnight in the refrigerator before warming.
      Yeast Cinnamon Rolls

      These rolls are lovingly made the old-fashioned way - with yeast and real butter, a single batch at a time. Light, doughy, and packed with brown sugar and cinnamon, these pillowy soft rolls are topped with silky icing to make them even more irresistible. Rolls are fully cooked. Thaw on counter for 1 hour or overnight in the refrigerator before warming.

      $29.95$29.95
        
      Pumpkin Spice Cinnamon Rolls. Infused with pumpkin spice & a generous swirl of sweet cinnamon, crowned with a velvety Cream Cheese Pumpkin Spice Icing"
      Pumpkin Spice Cinnamon Rolls

      Infused with pumpkin spice & a generous swirl of sweet cinnamon, crowned with a velvety Cream Cheese Pumpkin Spice Icing"

      $29.95$29.95
        
      "Pie Purse" Insulated Cooler Bag. Whether carrying your pie to Thanksgiving dinner or packing up the snacks for soccer, this insulated cooler bag can keep your items cold or hot and look good doing it. The perfect gift for moms on the go!
      "Pie Purse" Insulated Cooler Bag

      Whether carrying your pie to Thanksgiving dinner or packing up the snacks for soccer, this insulated cooler bag can keep your items cold or hot and look good doing it. The perfect gift for moms on the go!

      $39.95$39.95
        
      Gift Card Sweet Pie Product Image
      Gift Card Sweet Pie
      $37.50$37.50
        
      Gift Card Savory Pie Product Image
      Gift Card Savory Pie
      $42.50$42.50
        
      Total
      $0.00$0.00

      Credit Card

    • Should be Empty: