• Help protect Scotland's seas in just 15 minutes!

  • Join Our Seas and ask the Scottish Government to properly protect our Marine Protected Areas and coastal seas from scallop dredging and bottom trawling.

    Our Seas want to see at least 30% of Scotland’s inshore protected from more damaging fishing practices.

    We've selected five key questions and provided simple explanations and guidance to help you respond to a Scottish Government consultation in your own words.

    Contact us at info@ourseas.scot if you're interested in answering more questions in greater detail.

  • Q1. Do you support or oppose the proposed Option 1 fisheries management measures for inshore MPAs and proposed PMF management areas?

    This question asks whether you support Option 1, which would leave large areas of our ‘protected’ seas open to bottom trawling and dredging.

    Our Seas recommends you click Oppose below as Option 1 offers too little protection for Scotland's marine life.

    • In most cases, Option 1 leaves large areas within Marine Protected Areas exposed to bottom trawling and dredging. This means, even though many of these sites were set up because they’re home to important seabed habitats and species, many will still be exposed to damage under Option 1. Our Seas do not think this is acceptable.
    • Option 1 for priority marine features would still leave large areas where these species and habitats have been found exposed to trawling and dredging. This is unacceptable.
  • Q2. Do you have any comments on the proposed Option 1 zonal fisheries management measures?

    • Option 1 provides very limited protection for marine protected areas and are practically unenforceable for priority marine features due to their small size - restricting scallop dredging and bottom trawling from just 1.05% of inshore seas. 
    • A personal reason why you care about nature decline, or how better protection, and a healthier sea, could benefit the place you live
    • That we should leave nature alone to allow for recovery, benefiting marine life, coastal communities and sustainable businesses.
    • The proposals include measures which aim to look like they are doing something - such as banning hydraulic dredging - but since no hydraulic dredging actually takes place there anyway, they are sort of meaningless!
    • The lines on maps have been drawn based on existing fishing activity and by asking dredgers where they would accept as closures, meaning they allow the majority of the dredge and trawl impact to continue.  
  • Q3. Do you support or oppose the proposed Option 2 fisheries management measures for inshore MPAs and proposed PMF management areas?

     This question asks whether you support Option 2, which has stronger protection for our inshore environment. Our Seas support the stronger protections proposed for Marine Protected Areas, but the proposals for Priority Marine Features are still massively inadequate. 


    Our Seas recommends you click Support below but make sure you explain why they are not strong enough in Q4 below.

    • Our Seas support Option 2 proposals which close entire MPAs to bottom trawling and dredging (e.g. Fetlar). But Our Seas cannot support Option 2 proposals for protected areas where destructive fishing is still allowed (e.g. Clyde Sea Sill).
    • For priority marine features neither option 1 or 2 go far enough to provide the protection these fragile yet important species and habitats need.. As there isn’t an ‘alternate’ option to select Our Seas suggest you select ‘'support’'  for option 2 at a minimum but believe additional protection is required in the form of a modern version of the inshore limit adapted to the needs of Scotland's different coastal regions.
  • Q4. Do you have any comments on the proposed Option 2 full site fisheries management measures?

    Explain what you think should be protected and what the Government could do instead.

    Our Seas is calling for a modern inshore limit, tailored to different Scottish Marine Regions, we suggest this could look like:
    - Protection within one mile of the shore and in waters shallower than 45 metres as a default, but
    - A three-mile limit in the North west coast
    - Protection within one mile of the shore in the Western Isles
    - Full protection for MPA and PMF areas in Shetland instead

    • Option 2 only provides the minimum level of protection needed for meaningful seabed recovery and it is not enough. Our Seas think the Scottish Government could go further by implementing a modern version of the inshore limit. 
    • The proposals don't go far enough to restore healthy seas - and we already know that they are too small to deliver the legal responsibility of protecting the seabed, thanks to a report from Environmental Standards Scotland. 
    • Share how you or your wider community might be impacted by a lack of meaningful protection (e.g. how will nature loss impact your business or your connection to the natural world?)
    • Better protection could benefit coastal economies too. A Government commissioned study estimated that banning trawling within three nautical miles of the coast could increase gross value added by around £6 million.
    • Impacted fishermen need to be supported, either through compensation or support to transition to lower impact fishing methods.
  • Q620. Is there anything else you would like to tell us?

    This is your chance to tell the Scottish Government why Scotland's seas matter to you! Whether you love spending time by the coast, care about marine wildlife or want healthier seas for future generations, a few sentences in your own words can make your response more personal, which has the strongest impact!

  • Please provide your details for your responses to be recorded by the Scottish Government

  • Are you responding as an individual or an organisation?*
  • The Scottish Government would like your permission to publish your consultation response. Please indicate your publishing preference:*
  • Do you consent to Scottish Government contacting you again in relation to this consultation exercise?*
  • I consent to show my support for the Our Seas campaign and agree that my data will be processed and held according to the Our Seas privacy statement: https://www.ourseas.scot/privacy-statement/*
  • Should be Empty: