• Current Specialty Flavors — STORE USE ONLY

  • Cake orders require at least 4 days’ advance notice.

    • Select your pickup date below.
    • Select the 12:00 PM button to reserve your date.
    • Your cake may be picked up anytime between Noon–10 PM that day.
  • Choose Your Cake Pickup Date*
  • Format: (000) 000-0000.

  • 1. Choose Your Cake — $39.99 | Serves 10–12

    Select ONE cake from the gallery below. Once you've made your selection, click NEXT to build out your cake.
  • *

  • 2. Build Your Cake

  • Pumpkin Shortcake

  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with graham cracker crumbs around the base and top, with mallowcreme pumpkins on the dollops.

  • Pumpkin Cheesecake

  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with caramel sauce drizzle, cheesecake bites around the base and mallowcreme pumpkins on the dollops.

  • PB & Strawberry

  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with peanut butter sauce drizzle, chopped peanuts around the base and fresh sliced strawberries.

  • S'mores

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your SAUCE*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, graham cracker crumbs around the base and on top, dark chocolate chips sprinkled on the icing dollops.

  • Café Cravings

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your SAUCE*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with your selected sauce drizzle and Cookie Dough Bites on top and around the base.

  • Coconut Almond Fudge

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, chopped almonds around the base and coconut flakes and chopped almonds on top, and a piece of Mounds candy on each fluffy icing dollop!

  • Coconut Caramel Crunch

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with caramel drizzle, coconut caramel cookies, coconut and dark chocolate chips on top.

  • Banana Pudding

  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with graham cracker crumbs around the base and on top, plus Nilla wafers.

  • Kiwi's Cheesecake

  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with caramel drizzle, and cheesecake bites around the base and on the icing dollops.

  • Mookie's Cookies n' Cream

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, Oreo crumbs around the base and Oreo Cookies on the icing dollops.

  • Menchie's Favorite

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, and Oreo Cookies on the icing dollops.

  • Mellow's Cookie Dough

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your SAUCE*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with your selected sauce drizzle and Cookie Dough Bites on top and around the base.

  • Sundae Funday w/sprinkles

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, rainbow sprinkles on top and around the base, and dollops topped with maraschino cherries.

  • Sundae Funday w/nuts

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, rainbow sprinkles around the base, chopped peanuts on top and dollops topped with maraschino cherries.

  • Sprinkle's Celebration

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with rainbow sprinkles on top and around the base.

  • Chocoberry

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, Oreo crumbs around the base and on top, plus fresh sliced strawberries.

  • Barry's Shortcake

  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with graham cracker crumbs around the base and on top, plus fresh sliced strawberries.

  • Barry's Cheesecake

  • Choose your BOTTOM yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP color*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with cheesecake bites around the base and on top, plus fresh sliced strawberries.

  • Dandy Candy

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, and mini m&ms around the base and on top.

  • PB’s Peanut Butter Cup

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your SAUCE*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, and Reese’s Pieces on top and around the base.

  • Chip's Waffle Lotta Chocolate

  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, chocolate dipped waffle chips, brownie bites and dark chocolate chips.

  • Chocolate Almond Cloud

  • Choose your CAKE flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your TOP yogurt flavor*
  • Choose your ICING & DOLLOP flavor*

  • FINISHING TOUCHES

    Finished with chocolate drizzle, chopped almonds on top and around the base.

  • Your Cake Order Summary

    Please review your cake order and selected upgrades before submitting.

  • Sorry, Pumpkin Shortcake isn't available right now!

    This seasonal favorite requires Harvest Pumpkin frozen yogurt flavor that isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious combination of creamy Harvest Pumpkin frozen yogurt layered on white cake, with your choice of Cake Batter or Vanilla frozen yogurt and a center filled with graham cracker crumbs. Finished with graham cracker crumbs and adorable little mallowcreme pumpkins on the dollops!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this seasonal favorite returns!

  • Sorry, Pumpkin Cheesecake isn't available right now!

    This seasonal favorite requires Harvest Pumpkin frozen yogurt flavor that isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing! 

    A delicious combination of creamy Harvest Pumpkin frozen yogurt and rich New York Cheesecake frozen yogurt, layered on white cake and a center filled with caramel sauce and cheesecake bites. Finished with caramel drizzle, more cheesecake bites, and adorable little mallowcreme pumpkins!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this seasonal favorite returns!

  • Sorry, PB & Strawberry isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires peanut butter-flavored frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious frozen yogurt cake starting with a layer of white cake, topped with creamy peanut butter-flavored frozen yogurt, a center filled with rich peanut butter sauce and chopped peanuts, and a layer of Strawberry (No Sugar Added) frozen yogurt. Finished with peanut butter sauce drizzle, chopped peanuts around the base, and freshly sliced strawberries!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Sorry, S'mores isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires Toasty Marshmallow frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious frozen yogurt cake featuring rich Chocolate frozen yogurt on the bottom and creamy Toasty Marshmallow frozen yogurt on top, layered with your choice of white or chocolate cake. The center is filled with your choice of fudge or marshmallow cream sauce and graham cracker crumbs. Finished with chocolate drizzle, graham cracker crumbs around the base and on top, and dark chocolate chips sprinkled on the icing dollops!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Sorry, Café Cravings isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires coffee-flavored frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious frozen yogurt cake featuring rich, creamy coffee-flavored frozen yogurt paired with your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or caramel-flavored frozen yogurt. Layered with your choice of caramel or fudge sauce and delicious cookie dough bites in the center. Finished with your selected sauce drizzle and more cookie dough bites around the base and on the icing dollops!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Sorry, Coconut Almond Fudge isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires Fresh Coconut frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious frozen yogurt cake featuring rich chocolate and creamy coconut flavors, on a chocolate cake base, layered with coconut flakes, chopped almonds and fudge sauce. Finished with chocolate drizzle, chopped almonds around the base and on top, and a piece of Mounds candy on each fluffy icing dollop!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Sorry, Coconut Caramel Crunch isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires Fresh Coconut frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious frozen yogurt cake featuring your choice of caramel, vanilla, or chocolate frozen yogurt on the bottom, topped with creamy Fresh Coconut frozen yogurt. Between the layers, you'll find caramel sauce and coconut flakes. Finished with caramel drizzle, coconut caramel cookie pieces, topped with caramel, coconut and dark chocolate chips!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Sorry, Banana Pudding isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires Banana Pudding frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious frozen yogurt cake featuring creamy Banana Pudding frozen yogurt, layered with cake and sweet, pudding-inspired flavors for a delightful twist on the classic dessert!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Sorry, Kiwi's Caramel Cheesecake isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires caramel-flavored frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious frozen yogurt cake featuring creamy caramel frozen yogurt, layered with cake and a delicious cheesecake-inspired filling, then finished with sweet caramel touches for an irresistible caramel-and-cheesecake combination!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Sorry, Mookie's Cookies n' Cream isn't available right now!

    This specialty favorite requires Cookies n' Cream frozen yogurt, which isn't currently available. Please choose another delicious cake!

    Here's what you're missing!

    A delicious combination of Cookies n' Cream frozen yogurt and creamy chocolate or vanilla frozen yogurt, layered with your choice of white or chocolate cake. The center is filled with rich fudge sauce and Oreo cookie pieces, then finished with chocolate drizzle, Oreo crumbs around the base, and Oreo cookies on the icing dollops!

     

    Craving a slice? Check back soon to see when this specialty favorite returns!

  • Should be Empty: