As a community member, I support the permit application comments submitted by Save Enetai against the development proposal AND add my own comments to it.
1. Preliminary Plat 26-00781
ZONING
This permit application for 180 houses on 37 acres is not compatible with the surrounding density of the neighborhoods. Most ALL of the neighborhoods in Enetai were built out at 1-3 dwellings per acre in the 1960's with the limited exception of a few parcels. All are served by private septic, in part due to the steep topography, wetlands, streams and geologic hazards. 85% of the abutting parcels to the PPlat is zoned Restricted Residential and Greenbelt with 15% zoned Urban Low Residential. This kind of proposed density should not be allowed to overshadow neighborhoods already built out for decades at a much lower density, and when only 15% abuts a higher zoning that significantly impacts the character of the rural-like area.
The entire 65-acre estate that abuts the shoreline has been in Open Space since 1992 and considered environmentally sensitive land as evidenced by the Current Use Open Space Tax application and agreement signed by the Cheney family. An area-wide rezoning in 2016 had options to rezone this area to Greenbelt to match the shoreline to the north that has contiguous topography and critical areas. Ultimately, portions of the Enetai area were downzoned to Urban Restricted, however the previous owner of the 65-acre estate successfully reversed the zoning on a portion of the estate during a period it was up for sale for over a year and not selling. He claimed it was surrounded by high density neighborhoods which was not accurate. Not only was a "split zoning" applied to the entire estate with a boundary line adjustment, but a "spot zoning" was allowed for the benefit of the owner to improve his chances of a sale. These kind of zoning changes are generally frowned upon and questionable legally. This was ALL done without notice to surrounding neighbors and in conflict with the Open Space application.
FISH & WILDLIFE HABITAT & Illahee-Enetai Community Plan
The PPlat & SSDP parcels were defined in the "Illahee Community Plan" (incorporated into the Comprehensive Plan) in 2008 as a WDFW designated "wildlife patch" that connects by a series of wildlife corridors to Illahee State Park and Illahee Forest Preserve. WDFW lists it as a "Priority Species Habitat" area. In Dec 2024, the Kitsap County Board of County Commissioners approved Save Enetai's proposal to extend the boundaries of the Illahee Community Plan to create a "Illahee-Enetai Community Plan" starting the last quarter of 2025. The primary reason to extend the boundaries south was to accomplish further downzoning to areas with significant critical areas including steep slopes, geologically hazardous areas and preserve wildlife habitat. It was a logical extension however, in Dec 2025, the county told Save Enetai the rezoning would have to be delayed until 2028-2029. A month later, they agreed to proceed but person(s) at DCD undermined the entire effort by changing the scoping that was agreed to. Clearly, the area qualifies for lower zoning given the county's previous approval to do another area-wide downzoning and incorporate other comprehensive plan options presented in 2016.
According to the Illahee Community Plan, the "Cheney Estate and Enetai as a whole is approximately 100 acres of primary wildlife habitat." No where in this permit application is there mention of the dense forest canopy and the fact it is a designated wildlife patch and old growth forest. The displacement of wildlife and the destruction of centuries worth of flora and fauna and its impacts have gone totally ignored.
Aside from the above, it appears there are no buffers of any kind between the (3) adjacent neighborhoods (Viewcrest, Rozewood Estates and Enetai Beach). Lack of grading plan and extent of clearcut leaves huge omissions to this submission. So-called "vegetation buffers" and "existing vegetation buffers" are not defined at all. The huge impacts to these neighborhoods are omitted entirely.
CRITICAL AREAS
More detail will be provided in the SEPA comments about the critical areas on the property that appear to omitted in the permit application(s). Here are a few omissions:
Category I Critical Aquifer Recharge, WRIA 15 - Enetai Watershed.
Geological Hazardous Areas / Seattle Fault zone / Slope failures.
Wetlands, streams & ponds, water supply-well spring on property.
Deep ravines that connect to streams which ignore any buffers.
The SW corner of the development abuts to the top of slope of Enetai Creek, a fish bearing stream and another wildlife corridor, is totally ignored in this permit. This is another area of steep slopes, high erosion and constant landslides that surrounds the parcels that have not been considered and ignored.
The permit(s) fail to include (2) other adjacent parcels owned by the applicant impacted by the development and uses those parcels for wetlands mitigation. For example, wetlands "takes" for buffer reduction on the shoreline parcel appear to be "gives" in a large landslide scarp that is a 90 degree drop over 100- feet below.
SAFETY /TRAFFIC / INFRASTRUCTURE
The applicant failed to answer SEPA questions about planned improvements on existing roads, streets, pedestrian, or bicycle paths. The preliminary plat feasibility falls significantly short by entirely omitting improvements necessary to place a high -density development out on the outer edges of the UGA, where little to no infrastructure exists and utilities need to be extended to serve the development. Sidewalks, curbing as well as traffic control installations need to occur on 30th at the plat main entrance out to Trenton intersection, as well as on Helm Street where they intend to open a 2nd exit/entrance.
The TIA is deficient and omits safety issues within the subdivision of Rozewood Estates by the opening up of a road into this subdivision. The safety we now enjoy by the quiet dead end streets will be destroyed and a full opening of NE Helm Street for traffic in an out of this proposed development ignores the steep downhill grade and the hazards to pedestrians, children, pets and wildlife that roam the area. It is not acceptable to disrupt an entire neighborhood within Rozewood Estates with speeding downhill traffic not designed for increased capacity and/or without safety measures/mitigation. An Optimcom gate for emergency vehicles is better suited for this access point. Rozewood Estates subdivision should not have to bear the brunt of all the disruptions building this proposed subdivision brings when they have other access points.
SEWER: The applicant proposes to extend sewer from Perry Avenue down steep slopes, and crossing Enetai Creek, a fish-bearing stream, extending across Helm ripping up Rozewood Estates for a lengthy period of time disrupting resident's abilities to access our homes. There are other optional routes to extend sewer that don't disrupt an entire neighborhood at its only entrance. A separate SDAP and SEPA process should be applied to this sewer extension as it is a direct project of this proposed subdivision and lies within the unincorporated Kitsap County boundaries.
STORMWATER DRAINAGE/GRADING
The permit submissions fail to adequately address the extensive stormwater that flows onto the property off the entire hillside to the north off 30th. Stormwater is directly discharged onto this property via the limited KC stormwater drainage system. The limited civil plans omit how this will be engineered and it has very real implications to the feasibility of this proposed project. The minimal civil plans show fill in steep ravines and streambeds that exist on the property with no clear grading on the proposed lots.
Grading on the this heavily water-laden and sloped property is entirely omitted from this project and cut & fill numbers are far below what would be needed for a project of this size. These are critical pieces that require necessary full evaluations to determine feasibility of this project.
WATER
The developer has submitted a Non-binding water availability letter that only identifies North Perry Water District (NPWD) as the water purveyor that serves the area. There are no guarantee of water availability and currently there is a waiting list for large developments to be provided water that put access to water years away. NPWD has known water infrastructure and capacity issues and they have told Save Enetai that they cannot provide a binding water agreement for this proposed subdivision at this time. Kitsap County is well aware of these water issues.
2. Shoreline Substantial Development Permit 26-03503
The SSDP and PPlat fail to acknowledge the ENTIRE 65-acre site (shoreline + forest above) encompasses a whole functioning shoreline - from forest to tidelands. The combined parcels include 200+ year old forest, historic salt marsh embayment, two creeks, three wetlands, two acres of state tidelands, and 1548'of low bank shoreline, of which 838' includes high-functioning feeder bluffs and bluff backed beach. The property's mature forest, feeder bluffs, and shoreline provide important ecological functions that, together, create habitat for a variety of native terrestrial and marine species, both within and beyond the properties boundaries.
The property's active feeder bluffs also provide important sediment inputs that drive sediment transport and accretion processes for three miles downdrift. This creates pocket beaches in the nearshore environment that provide spawning habitat for surf smelt, less than 2000' feet north of the property and part of that same drift cell is Pacific lance spawning habitat, and just offshore is a pre-spawner holding area for Pacific herring. These three species of forest fish form a critical link in the Puget Sound marine food web, including serving as a major food source for marine birds and salmonids, which in turn make up more than 80% of the endangered Southern Resident Killer Whale diet.
The cumulative impacts from clear cutting a 37-acre old growth forest (PPlat) on the shoreline parcels and their inter-connectiveness are not addressed in either permit and cannot be ignored. This stormwater pipeline (SSDP) permit fails to address the Conservatory designation and sensitive near-shore environments that are at risk. These upland forest-shoreline functions work together and if the groundwater and water laden soils are interrupted, it would destroy the wetlands, streams and ecological balance to the natural shoreline below.
Stormwater discharge into the Puget Sound causes severe ecological, physical and economic damages. Improperly or untreated runoff flows directly from impervious surfaces (like roads, roof, & parking lots) into coastal waters, introduces a toxic mix of pollutants that degrade intertidal and marine habitats. Toxic synthetic chemicals like 6PPD-quinone (from tire wear) wash off roads during rain events and cause acute pre-spawn mortality in salmon. Bioaccumulated toxins move up the marine food web from small invertebrates to forage fish, sea birds, marine mammals, and resident orcas.
Large volumes of loose soil and fine sediment cloud the water column (increase turbidity) and settle heavily over intertidal mudflats and sand bars. This layer of sediment blocks sunlight from reaching underwater plact and can physically suffocate clams, oysters and other sessile shellfish. High volume, fast moving surges of stormwater scour intertidal channels, erode shoreline and disrupt the delicate substrate stability that eel grass, clams and juvenile fish rely upon. Impacts to adjacent neighbors along the Enetai Beach shoreline to the south, where there are known oyster beds have not been studied or even considered in permit submissions. These submissions are incomplete.
Ignoring all these impacts above and only looking at stormwater outfall alone and presenting it as a "simple pipe being laid upon the ground" is a faulty and deficient evaluation. Additionally, there is no technical data about the intake for this line which should be oversized to ensure all water from high intensity flooding as there is no acceptable overflow route. This inter-connectiveness between the forest and shoreline warrants a full hydrogeologic study as part of an overall Environmental Impact Study (EIS).
3. The expected DNS (determination of non-significance) fails to adequately address all the environmental impacts of this project and the degree the development causes significant unmitigatable impacts. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) should be required and "independent" 3rd Party experts hired to perform it. The applicant appears to have combined the two permits (Pplat & SSDP) into ONE SEPA check sheet that has errors and omits accurate descriptions.
These submissions are incomplete. The SEPA comment period should be extended and/or restarted once the entire document is provided for review. The applicant should be obligated to a level of completeness of information submitted of proposed activity for a SEPA determination. The most egregious areas of deficient information, are as follows:
Hydrogeologic and geotechnical evaluation of the preliminary plat proposal on the adjacent landslide hazard with recommendations of lot grading and buffer reduction to prevent aggravation or acceleration of landslide activity along the existing scarp and address public safety. This evaluation cannot be performed without; a complete grading plan detailing fill and clearing limits for viable lot configuration that, would support house foundations and stormwater conveyance, and fill slope stabilization which are absent in this application. This should not be deferred to future owners. The fill that would be necessary for house foundations is needed to insure there is a feasible path for the proposed impervious surface stormwater collection proposed by the applicant as a crucial mitigation. In addition, the entirety of fill proposed to make preliminary plat lots viable needs to accessed by a professional hydrogeologist with regards to the adjacent landslide hazard and earthquakes associated with the Seattle fault line(s) that runs through the area.
The county should require the hydrogeologist and geotechnical reports evaluating the adequacy of structure and fill setbacks and buffer protection required to guard public safety and environmental impacts that can occur if the adjacent landslide hazard is aggravated. Simply complying with general steep slope setbacks does not constitute adequate protection and no assumption of significant impact.
Save Enetai is submitting a qualified expert review by Greg Wessel, PhD & licensed Engineering Geologist of the applicant's Geotechnical report that strongly recommends a more in-depth study be prepared by a consultant with expertise in evaluating ACTIVE landslides. Of note, the applicants geotechnical report proposes they will provide an addendum addressing monitoring well data collected during the wet season. To date, this addendum has not been provided or posted for public review.
The applicant is short of providing adequate detail of proposed elements of development needed for a SEPA determination to be made.
The applicant has not provided a detailed plan showing the stormwater tightline route and outfall footprint to evaluate sensitive area impacts. Standard water quality treatment does not confirm non-significant impact has been met for the nearshore area and/or stream confluence. We have no assurance or detail of sensitive areas impacted by the proposed conveyance line and the associated energy dissipation structure. Applicant is required by Department of Ecology to have on-site visit with Department of Ecology SEA staff, WA Department of Fish & Wildlife staff, and Tribal staff to confirm wetland and streams within the project footprint and to observe conditions within and around the project's proposed stormwater outfall. This application is incomplete without these actions, among others, until completed.
The applicant is proposing urban lot density expanded into what should be a conservancy area due to its unique mature forest habitat and adjacent severe active landslide hazards.
There is insufficient evaluation of the high-density impact to traffic especially the intersection of 30th & Trenton and secondly, the routing of daily trips on Helm Street with no proposed vehicular and pedestrian safety measures. If the county agrees to extend urban density, then the developer should be required to provide traffic and pedestrian safety to frontages and roadways impacted by the traffic trips generated by full build out.
OTHER SPECIFIC SEPA COMMENTS by Number in Check Sheet:
8. Both the Critical Areas & Geotechnical report do not fully evaluate the high geological hazards on the property and fail to address the cumulative impacts to the entire forest to shoreline ecosystem. The geotechnical reports and application omit that the property lies within the Seattle fault zone and any potential fire hazards that exists.
Overall, the application does not consider that the shoreline and bluffs from Illahee to Enetai are prone to high erosion and landslides. Historical slides at Illahee State Park to the north are numerous and in the 1950's took out the entire clam population on the shoreline. Bahia Vista neighborhood to the south of the state park has had several slides that took out roads and the county just spent $800K to repair a segment. The Viewcrest neighborhood directly adjacent to this proposal was built in the 1950's and 60's. It has a long history of water intrusions in basements, cracked foundations and sliding hillside. The same goes for many properties to south of the proposed development that lie east of Trenton Avenue down into Manette. These geological hazards and public safety concerns are well known and documented. The applicant simply has not proved feasibility of such a large development on this hillside. It appears the application is trying to disguise the property limitations for a financially viable proposal.
9. The applicant does NOT disclose they have been in negotiations with Great Peninsula Conservancy land trust to purchase the property. There are grant proposals for state and federal funds that have been awarded or are pending. JARPA forms have been submitted to the Army Corp of Engineers and the stormwater pipeline on the shoreline parcel needs to be approved by Department of Ecology, along with the tribes and WDFW. The applicant at this time has declined to put in an HPA permit or have WDFW do a site visit to identify potential impacts to the streams.
10. The applicant omits the permit of the Shoreline Substantial Development Permit from this line item that need approvals.
11. This development extends to a total of (5) parcels and approximately 50 acres, these two permits go well beyond 36.70 acres listed by the applicant.
12. There are no site plans, vicinity map and/or topographical map attached to this SEPA Checklist. The description of the location is vague and difficult to determine without a vicinity map.
B. ENVIRONMENTAL ELEMENTS
1b. Steepest slope on the parcels is a massive scarp with a sheer drop of 90 degrees in the landslide area. If the applicant is going to combine the two permits on one SEPA checklist, it should be delineated. The steep ravines exceed the 36% listed on the check sheet.
1c. Further, more in depth geotechnical study would identify accurate description of soils.
1d. GeoResources does not have the expertise to be issuing a report in an ACTIVE landslide area and failed to consider hydrogeological characteristics of the hillside which would require an independent 3rd party qualified to study it. An expert reviewed the report and listed its deficiencies in our attached report.
1e. The applicant failed to submit a grading plan and the cut and fill quantities are substantially low given the massive grading that would occur with this development. The permit submissions fail to show extent of clear cut and stripping boundaries.
1g. 41% of impervious surface is a low estimate.
2. AIR
2a. The impact of dust that will be generated by a clearing and grading of the forest in the air is entirely omitted. It fails to consider the high winds that come across the hillside and at the top of the forest boundary they appear to intend to clear cut. Temperature increases by stripping the land of dense forest cover and adding impervious surfaces are omitted.
2c. Dust control measures are not planned, considered and are omitted. High winds are omitted and not considered.
3. WATER
3a1. The applicant has failed to list Enetai Creek, a type F fish-bearing creek which is bordered by this development in the SW corner that flows south, then SE into the Puget Sound. There is a pond offsite and wetlands directly adjacent to the NW corner of the project. The Critical Areas Report minimizes the extent of wetlands boundaries. This will be addressed in another comment letter in detail.
3a2. The pipeline encroaches up and across wetlands and stream including but not limited to buffers with no plan by the applicant to have a site visit with WDFW.
3a4. The applicant claims no surface water withdrawals or diversions will be required. The general plat map shows fill in ravines that feed streams with no buffer's applied to them. Once clear cut and graded, all the surface water will be diverted via direct discharge to shoreline. This diversion of surface and groundwater will significantly degrade and/or destroy the function of streams flowing off the hillside (feeder bluffs) and wetlands below.
3a6. Without a grading plan, this is difficult to quantify. Any clear cutting and grading will reasonably flow downhill, especially during high water events.
3b1 (GROUND). There is a artesian well spring box and potable water source that feeds to the shoreline residents on the property.
3b2. Applicant fails to answer the question entirely.
3c: WATER RUNOFF (including stormwater)
3c1. The applicant has not provided sufficient information to determine the filtration (Filtera) and collection system is adequate. It's unknown who will provide maintenance to this system.
3c2. Applicant proposes to place sewer pump station above drinking water well, stream and perched the pump station at the top of a slope known for high geologic hazards, unstable slopes and high erosion.
3c3. On-site stormwater management plan is unclear. Drainage patterns that will be altered have direct impacts to shoreline ecosystem, streams and wetlands.
3d. Applicant only proposes on-site stormwater management to control surface water with no mention of Category 1 Aquifer Recharge. The submissions fail to address direct impacts by alternative drainage patterns and diversions of ground water and/or ravines that feed streams.
4. PLANTS
4b. Applicant fails to answer the question re: amount to be removed or describe the floor vegetation.
4c. Applicant fails to disclose known Eagle nests and bald eagles present in the area that are considered a "threatened" species. Early submissions and within the permit notes identify the nests as being present.
4d. Lack of grading and detailed landscaping plan make it difficult to determine actual open space area and area to be planted. It appears that up to 66% of the dense forest canopy may be removed? This conflicts with calculations for impervious surface. Not enough information to determine applicable Tree Canopy credits.
4e. There is invasive species within the forest. A significant amount can be seen on the north boundary of the proposed subdivision along 30th.
5. ANIMALS
5a, b & c. The applicant fails to list all the wildlife in this WDFW designated wildlife patch including threatened Bald Eagles. This is a migration route for several birds.
5d. This answer falls short due to lack of grading and clearing plan. The entire 37+ acres above the top of slope appears will be clear-cut destroying a known WDFW designated wildlife patch and wildlife corridor. This is an old growth forest and by clearing the land, ALL the flora, fauna and wildlife habitat will be destroyed. Clearing the forest above will significantly impact the wetlands and shoreline ecosystem below. This will NOT minimize the impacts to local flora & fauna, it will destroy it.
6. ENERGY & NATURAL RESOURCES
6b. Applicant admits extensive timber harvest will increase overall sun exposure. This will destroy the forest canopy that cleans the air in an urban setting. Adding impervious surface will increase temperatures around the area.
7. ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
7a1. With the construction, there is risk of fire danger with the dense forest that is not addressed or considered.
7a2. Underground gas lines, including cable and electric run along portions of the western boundary of proposed development.
7b2. Noise: Applicant fails to answer question fully. re: types of construction, length of short & long-term construction. Does not address equipment that causes earth vibrations and impacts to homes next to the area of construction. Working 7:00am to 10:00pm next to residential neighborhoods is not allowed by code. The developed omits any noise berms which are necessary during construction.
7b3. The applicants report do not detail extent of earth disturbance re: boundaries nor define "existing vegetative buffers" or widths.
8. LAND & SHORELINE USE
8a. Developer fails to describe impacts to surrounding properties. There is undeveloped land next to the NW corner of the development that is wetlands and has a pond. There is undeveloped land to the south of the development boundaries in area known as Enetai Beach neighborhood.
8c. There are several structures on the shoreline parcels and a Well Spring housing and cistern that serves potable water to the shoreline. The water pipeline runs adjacent to a portion of the road where the tightline is proposed.
8e. Not all parcels owned by applicant are listed in the permit submissions. They have combined SEPA checklists and leaving out the other parcels that are zoned Urban Restricted (1-5).
8g. The SMP designation on the shoreline parcel that is a part of this development is "Urban Conservancy."
8h. Category I Aquifer Recharge should be included. Wildfire hazards and ACTIVE landslide. Geologic hazard evaluation is insufficient. See letter submitted by Greg Wessel, PhD, Leg.
8j. No mitigation plan for displacement of wildlife.
8k. Hundreds of wildlife will be displaced by this development. We the people who live next to this forest and enjoy them in our neighborhoods have a say about this displacement.
8l. The surrounding parcels are zoned restricted and greenbelt, with only 15% of the proposed development boundary next to Urban Low. The neighborhoods have been built out as 1-3 dwelling per acre and are on medium to large lots. This high density on postage size lots are not compatible with the surrounding area. The developer is proposing to make a secondary entrance/exit on the border of Rozewood Estates and open up what is now a dead-end road without addressing the safety hazards.
9. HOUSING
9a. It is a certainty, with ocean views for single family homes will NOT be low-income and does not follow GMA and Kitsap County Comprehensive Plan.
10. AESTHETICS
10a. In keeping with the Illahee Community Plan, the abutting hillside neighborhood between Sylvan Way and 30th is part of Enetai. It currently has View Restrictions that need to be applied to this development.
10b. The applicant fails to define "vegetation buffer", buffer widths and locations. The is no grading map that shows the extent of clear-cutting of the forest. It is deficient.
10c. The development most certainly will alter the aesthetics of the neighborhood. Developer has failed to adequately answer the question.
11. LIGHT & GLARE
11b. The lights will impact the wildlife in the area particularly owls and bats native to this area.
11d. Applicant fails to propose ANY measures for mitigation to adjacent neighbors re: glare and animals.
12. RECREATION
12a. The middle school is 0.3 miles by how the crow flies, not walking distance. The students would have to cross Enetai Creek which is steep canyons and ravines and unwalkable. They would have to walk on Trenton, a busy road without sidewalks to accomplish the trek, that would be uphill.
12b. The surrounding community has enjoyed for centuries the walking paths in this dense forest. It is also used my mountain bikers. This property has been in Open Space since 1993 and has never been developed and is an old growth forest.
13. HISTORIC & CULTURAL PRESERVATION
13a. This estate has history attached to it as the former owner William Bremer, played a significant role in the formation of Bremerton, the shipyard and naval hospital. The shoreline in Enetai was served by the old Mesquito fleet and was the historic site of the first Mill & Shipyard. Ben Cheney, well known Tacoma timber magnate also owned this estate for decades, until 2018.
13b. There is evidence of tribal tools, artifacts and potential site of several old long houses. The forest is filled with evidence of culturally modified red cedar trees that are becoming endangered species of trees.
13c. The applicant's statement is patently false. Save Enetai has brought up the historical nature of this property on numerous occasions. The applicant is referencing Bremerton City Council meetings that were related to the sewer line extension which they made clear had no bearing on any future development. This statement is not applicable to this permit process. Save Enetai filed suit against the applicant and the City of Bremerton over this sewer line extension. We KNOW the truth!
13d. The applicant fails to acknowledge or address the loss of habitat by destroying WDFW designated "wildlife patch" and Priority Species Habitat, wind breaks and disruptions to the surrounding neighborhoods which include concerns about safety and infrastructure. The inadequate submissions fail to address the cumulative impacts to the shoreline functions and critical areas.
14. TRANSPORTATION
14a. The applicant omits any traffic or pedestrian safety issues for the Rozewood Estates neighborhood by proposing to open up Helm Street which, is a steep grade with no sidewalks. Additionally, there is no plan that show buffers/widths between the new development and the existing developments that abut it. The Rozewood Estates neighborhood adamantly opposes an opening that brings more traffic, congestion and safety issues to the area.
14b. The SEPA checklist fails to accurately list than Kitsap Transit's route 229 on Trenton runs only for short 3-hour commuter hours daily and is limited. It often is cancelled when there is a shortage of drivers due to its limited hours of operation. Route 223 that runs down Perry Avenue to the west is the only regular transit route and walking distance involves steep hills without sidewalks.
14c. The proposal most certainly will require improvements to existing roads, streets, stop lights and particularly sidewalks for pedestrians and bicycle lanes. The proposal is deficient and a critical required component to decide feasibility.
14e. An evaluation of the need for traffic control lights at 30th due to speed and poor site distance and definately curb and sidewalk protection and mass transit stop should be required.
15. PUBLIC SERVICES
15a. This project will increase need for public transit.
15b. Sidewalks need to be installed so residents can walk safely to transit stops.
16. UTILITIES
16b. The developer has proposed a sewerline extension from Perry Ave that will connect to City of Bremerton existing sewer. The application fails to address the route of intented sewer and this disruption to several neighborhoods, as well as SEPA issues related to installing a new utility across Enetai Creek, a F-designated stream. This sewer line extension lies within the incorporated Kitsap county jurisdiction and the environmental impacts need to be considered at this stage and go well beyond soley issuing a ROW permit alone for its construction. It should be noted that new construction of road improvements on Perry Avenue are subject to a building moratorium of 5 years. The proposed route off Perry Avenue down Fruitland to Helm Street, crossing Trenton and up Helm street needs to reconsidered as a preferred route.
D. SUPPLEMENTAL SHEET
1. The applicant's submissions are deficient and fail to detail how the increase of stormwater from increased impervious surface will be captured and treated.
2. The applicant's submissions are deficient and fail to detail the HUGE impact and displacment this is to the wildlife in the forest, a WDFW designated "wildlife patch" they propose to cut down. It also fails to consider how destroying this habitat will impact the other Wildlife patches in interconnects with such as Illahee State Park & Illahee Forest Preserve.
This proposal fails to consider the huge impact to the sensitive shoreline ecosystem that goes well beyond the proposed plat boundaries. The applicant's input is cut off mid-sentence and not complete. No map in the submissions locate the clearing limits of this project.
3. The removal of the dense forest canopy is a natural resource and will create higher temperatures, and increase poor air quality. It serves to protect surrounding areas from high winds and will have significant impacts.
4. The applicants comment is patently false. The Open Space documents (1993) outline these parcels as environmentally sensitive. It ignores the presence of Enetai Creek, a fish bearing stream for which is borders. Historical maps show the presence of a stream at the north end of the plat parcel that shows a stream bed on the ground. Stormwater from the adjacent hillside discharge into the stream. The developer proposes to fill that stream bed.
There is threatened species on this property which their habitat has been documented. The surrounding neighbors have enjoyed regular sitings of Bald Eagles that have nests in the forests. There are other species that have been seen but not fully documented such as spotted owl, pilated woodpeckers and bats. Bear and cougar are regularly seen in the area.
This area has historical and cultural significance. There is evidence that documents this and well known in the community. It is recognized formally by the Kitsap Historical Society.
The impacts to the shoreline are absent from the applicant's submissions. To say that the project would not impact the shoreline use is a farce unless the applicant wants to propose limitations, fencing and signage to prevent residents and the public access to what has been a private community and inaccessible by the public.
7. The permit submissions are deficient and fail to adequately protect the critical areas on and above the shoreline. The applicant has already violated Federal law by taking geotechnical heavy equipment on to protected Bald Eagle habitat without a permit. There has also been violation of the Open Space Tax Agreement that restricts ALL disturbing of vegetation, motorized vehicles and loud noises onto the environmentally sensitive parcels. There are NO exceptions in the Open Space tax Agreement to these restrictions.
In closing, I request the completeness of these application(s)and expected DNS be rescinded and require regions for completeness submitted and the comprehensive evaluation of the landslide hazard. Alternately this can be referred to a full EIS due to these concerns in addition to sensitive impacts not addressed for the tight line proposed. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on these permit applications.