Background Paper
Why we are seeking an ASMOF Victoria Rule 86 plebiscite
A stronger, more effective and accountable union
The October 2026 interim Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) was accepted by a narrow majority of ASMOF Victoria members.
We recognise that many members who voted YES considered the agreement the best available outcome in difficult circumstances.
However, our concerns are considerably broader than the agreement itself. They concern the planning and execution of the bargaining campaign, significant procedural difficulties surrounding industrial action, the independence of representation, member consultation and leadership accountability.
We believe these events have substantially undermined members' confidence in ASMOF Victoria, at a time when effective collective representation is more important than ever.
1. Bargaining strategy and missed opportunities
Enterprise bargaining commenced in 2025, yet by October 2026 members were being told that the approaching Victorian election made a comprehensive agreement unlikely before the government entered caretaker arrangements.
This raises questions about the adequacy of the overall bargaining strategy.
Was industrial escalation planned early enough? Were foreseeable political constraints properly anticipated? Why was substantial industrial pressure being applied so late in the bargaining cycle?
There are also questions about whether ASMOF made sufficient use of external expertise, including experienced industrial campaigners, other unions and the broader union movement.
We do not know what assistance was sought or what alternative strategies were considered. That is precisely why an independent review is needed.
The government was undoubtedly a difficult negotiating counterpart. However, a difficult negotiating environment makes competent preparation and strategic leadership more important, not less.
2. Procedural failures and disrupted industrial action
Particularly serious questions arise from the handling of protected industrial action.
August 2026
A planned 3½-hour stoppage on 13 August was postponed following a government challenge concerning the adequacy of industrial-action notifications.
ASMOF disputed the challenge and maintained that its notification was adequate. Nevertheless, the proposed action did not proceed as planned.
September 2026
A major statewide 24-hour stoppage scheduled for 15 September was also cancelled at the last minute amid legal challenges concerning notification and patient-safety arrangements.
Separately, Fair Work Commission decision [2026] FWC 3582, dated 17 September, records that:
ASMOF's protected-action ballot results had been declared on 28 July 2026.
The initial statutory 30-day commencement period had expired before ASMOF sought an extension.
The Commission granted an extension effective 17 September, two days after the proposed statewide stoppage.
The decision does not establish that the strike was unlawful or that the expired commencement period alone caused its cancellation. The statutory requirements also depend on whether the relevant types of industrial action had already commenced within the authorised period.
Nevertheless, these circumstances raise an obvious question:
How did ASMOF find itself confronting an expired statutory commencement period and repeated procedural challenges at critical stages of an industrial campaign?
These were not minor inconveniences. Planned action was disrupted, members were left uncertain and the campaign risked losing momentum.
An independent review should establish whether these difficulties were foreseeable, whether appropriate legal and procedural advice was obtained, and whether they could have been avoided.
3. Communication throughout the campaign
Members have raised concerns about the quality, timing and substance of communication during bargaining.
Although campaign updates and meetings occurred, questions remain about whether members were adequately informed of the strategic choices being made on their behalf.
Members should understand why industrial action is postponed or withdrawn, what alternatives are being considered, what bargaining opportunities remain and how the overall strategy is progressing.
Meaningful consultation is more than announcing decisions after they have been made.
A union asking members to sacrifice income, reorganise clinical commitments and participate in industrial action has a corresponding responsibility to provide clear, timely and candid information.
4. Independence and potential conflicts of interest
Some members have expressed concern about arrangements under which union representatives simultaneously occupy hospital executive, management or departmental leadership positions.
Those positions do not automatically create actual conflicts or establish misconduct. However, responsibilities to hospital employers may intersect with obligations to union members.
Members are entitled to expect clear disclosure, independent assessment and appropriate management of actual, potential and perceived conflicts of interest.
The review should consider whether existing arrangements adequately protect independent representation, including whether additional disclosure, recusal or structural safeguards are required.
It is essential that members have confidence that those negotiating on their behalf can represent their interests independently.
5. The October ballot: a different result was a realistic possibility
On 8 October, members overwhelmingly rejected the government's first interim offer, with approximately 89% voting NO.
Less than two weeks later, a revised offer was put to members.
Voting opened at 2 pm on 19 October and closed at noon the following day, providing just 22 hours to consider and vote on the proposal.
The members' information session was held five hours after voting had already commenced.
Significant concerns included:
- Members were not provided with the complete MOU before voting.
- Important qualifications concerning the offer, including the scope of permanent employment provisions, became clearer during the information session.
- Some members reported not receiving ballot notifications.
- Incorrect or inconsistent advice was provided about changing votes.
- Council strongly recommended acceptance before members had heard the discussion at the information session.
- Members advocating rejection had very limited opportunity to organise and communicate their position.
The declared result was:
| Result |
Votes |
| YES |
2847 |
| NO |
2657 |
| Margin |
190 |
| Formal Votes |
5504 |
| Informal Submissions |
644 |
| Yes percentage |
51.73% |
Just 96 members changing their votes from YES to NO would have reversed the result.
This is particularly significant given anecdotal reports of members, including junior doctors, who initially relied on the union's recommendation but reconsidered their position after receiving further information at the members' meeting.
We cannot independently establish how many members would have changed their votes. However, given the exceptionally narrow margin, it is entirely reasonable to regard a different outcome as a realistic possibility had members been afforded adequate notice, complete information and a proper opportunity to reconsider their decisions.
The 644 informal submissions raise further questions about verification, exclusions and attempted vote changes. They do not establish that valid votes were wrongly excluded, but their treatment warrants independent examination.
The issue is not simply whether the votes were counted correctly. It is whether the ballot provided a fair and informed expression of members' wishes.
In our view, the acknowledged deficiencies were potentially decisive and warranted independent scrutiny before the result was treated as settled.
6. The response afterwards and the apology
The handling of members' concerns following the ballot has compounded the damage to confidence.
ASMOF acknowledged shortcomings but declined to conduct a further ballot. Its subsequent communications emphasised the security of the vote count, the difficult negotiating circumstances and the reasons for proceeding with the agreement.
These explanations did not adequately address the cumulative impact of the procedural deficiencies or whether a different result might reasonably have occurred.
A subsequent apology concerning how members were treated when raising concerns acknowledged an important problem. However, an apology without meaningful accountability for the underlying decisions risks making matters worse rather than better.
Members do not simply want reassurance that their concerns have been heard. They want to know what went wrong, how decisions were reached, whether mistakes could have been avoided and what will change.
Acknowledging shortcomings while declining independent examination is unlikely to restore confidence.
7. The damage to goodwill, solidarity and membership
Perhaps one of the most disappointing consequences has been the apparent loss of goodwill and collective momentum generated during the campaign.
Doctors across Victoria participated in industrial action, attended rallies, engaged with colleagues and helped bring considerable public attention to the pressures facing the medical workforce.
The overwhelming rejection of the first interim offer demonstrated substantial member engagement and a willingness to act collectively.
That solidarity was a valuable achievement in its own right.
Yet the subsequent disruptions, compressed ballot, narrow outcome and handling of members' concerns appear to have eroded much of that goodwill.
We have heard reports of members resigning from the union in frustration, while others have expressed serious doubts about retaining their membership. We do not have verified resignation figures, and the extent of membership losses should be established rather than assumed.
However, even the emergence of these reports should concern ASMOF's leadership.
A union depends on more than membership subscriptions. It depends on members trusting their representatives, participating in campaigns, encouraging colleagues to join and being prepared to take collective action.
If the conduct of a campaign leaves previously engaged members disillusioned, disengaged or resigning, that represents a potentially significant loss of collective strength.
The consequences extend beyond the October MOU. They may affect ASMOF's capacity to mobilise members and negotiate effectively when substantive enterprise bargaining resumes.
The independent review should therefore examine not only bargaining outcomes and procedural compliance, but also the effect of these events on membership confidence, engagement, retention and the union's future industrial effectiveness.
8. What are we seeking?
The Rule 86 petition proposes five resolutions:
- A vote concerning confidence in the Victoria Branch Council and Executive.
- An independent external review of bargaining strategy, industrial action and governance.
- Independent scrutiny of the October MOU ballot.
- Stronger protections for independence and the management of conflicts of interest.
- Meaningful reforms to communication, democratic participation, ballot procedures and bargaining accountability.
Our objective is not to overturn the executed MOU. Although the ballot process raises questions that may have legal implications, we believe members' interests are better served by independent scrutiny, leadership accountability and meaningful reform than by litigation over the interim agreement.
Our priority is to ensure that the mistakes of 2026 are properly examined and not repeated when substantive bargaining resumes.
9. Lasting change requires new leadership and member participation
While the proposed plebiscite provides an important mechanism for accountability, it should not be seen as an end in itself.
A vote of no confidence can express members' dissatisfaction, but it will not, by itself, guarantee meaningful change.
Ultimately, the most effective and enduring way for members to influence the direction of their union is through participation in its democratic structures, including standing for election to the Victoria Branch Council and Executive.
We strongly encourage members who are dissatisfied with the present leadership, particularly those with experience, commitment and a willingness to represent their colleagues, to consider nominating for elected positions when eligible.
We also encourage members to identify and support capable colleagues who may be prepared to take on these responsibilities.
ASMOF needs representatives who are independent, approachable, accountable and prepared to undertake the substantial work required to represent doctors effectively.
This is not about replacing one group of officeholders simply for the sake of doing so. It is about attracting new perspectives, experience, energy and leadership to an organisation that has the potential to be a much stronger advocate for its members.
There is little value in expressing no confidence in the current leadership if members are unwilling to participate in building something better.
Members who have considered leaving the union in frustration should also consider whether remaining involved and helping elect new representatives may offer a more effective means of achieving the changes they want.
A genuine fresh start will require more than a plebiscite. It will require members to become actively involved in shaping the union's future.
10. Why sign, even if you voted YES?
Supporting the interim MOU and supporting stronger union governance are entirely compatible positions.
You may have considered the interim agreement the best available outcome while remaining concerned about bargaining strategy, procedural mistakes, communication or accountability.
You may even have confidence in some aspects of ASMOF's leadership while wanting independent scrutiny of others.
Signing this petition is not a vote of no confidence and does not indicate support for or opposition to any individual resolution. It simply requests that members be given the opportunity to vote on the five proposals under Rule 86.
We hope the process encourages greater member participation, including more candidates willing to put themselves forward for elected office.
Ultimately, our objective is a stronger, more transparent and more effective ASMOF Victoria.
A union should emerge from a major industrial campaign with greater member confidence and solidarity, not less. We believe the events of 2026 warrant independent examination, meaningful reform and renewed member participation so that confidence can be rebuilt.