J3-B: Evaluation Form
FOR COMPLETION BY EVALUATING JUDGES ONLY
PLEASE DO NOT COMPLETE FOR PROSPECTIVE JUDGE SERVING AS CLERK ON SPECIAL AWARDS PANEL.
Please fill out and complete the J3-B only if you are the evaluating judge. To complete this form, you will need information from the J3-A, submitted by the candidate or prospective judge. Please check your email for J3-A submissions from candidate and prospective judges, or refer to any J3-A hard copy print-outs that have been provided to you.
Please be advised that you will need to fill in information from the J3-A into the Section One spaces below.
Evaluee's first name:
Evaluee's last name:
Zone Judging Representative's email address:
Please choose evaluee's current designation:
Select "C" for Candidate and "P" for Prospective Judge
Evaluee's judging discipline:
When did evaluee commence this level?
Is this the evaluee's first assignment as a Candidate or Prospective Judge?
Club or organization sponsoring the show:
Type of show:
GCA zone show
GCA Annual Meeting show
GCA major show
Non-GCA major show
Other type of show
Date of Show
Your (the evaluating judge's) first name:
Your (the evaluating judge's) last name:
Your club or organization:
Your email address:
Your judging discipline:
Evaluate the Candidate (please do not fill out for Prospective Judge). Did the Candidate:
Identify herself and her role in the judging program?
Understand the layout of the Division and the class locations judged by your panel?
Take logical and sufficient notes during deliberations?
Accurately transcribe the judges" crafted comments?
Accurately place the awards?
Contribute in any other way requested?
Listen and stay focused?
Judge's comments on the Candidate Judge (please write thoughtful and specific comments):
Evaluate the Prospective Judge (please do not fill out for Candidate Judge). Did the Prospective Judge:
Use the principles and elements of design (Floral Design) or composition (Photography)?
Show plants and classes knowledge (Horticulture)?
Demonstrate an understanding of technical skills (Photography)?
Distinguish between the ordinary and the distinctive?
Show consideration and respect for the show, exhibits, and fellow judges?
Demonstrate preparedness for the show and schedule?
Participate in the discussion phase?
Show articulation in the comment writing phase?
Prove to be a good member of a panel?
Exercise impartiality and ability to put personal preference aside?
Listen well and work willingly towards consensus?
Contribute sound constructive comments and identify the exhibit"s strengths?
Judge's comments on the Prospective Judge (please write thoughtful and specific comments):
Letter of Recommendation for Prospective Judge:
Would you be willing to write a letter for this prospective judge when the time comes for advancement?
If you would like to discuss further, please call me at the number below.
Non-GCA judges contact information:
Should be Empty: