Hall of Fame Eligibility Criteria
Must be a graduate of Carlisle/Hartford HS (at least 10 years removed)
Individual Athlete Criteria (meet at least one criterion)
- State Champion
- State Runner-Up
- Selected First-Team All-State by one of the following organizations
- Iowa Newspaper Association (INA)
- Iowa Girls High School Athletic Union (IGHSAU)
- Iowa High School Athletic Association (IHSAA)
- The Des Moines Register
- Collegiate Accomplishments
- 1st, 2nd, or 3rd Team All-American
- 1st, 2nd, or 3rd Place in a NCAA Individual event for D- I, II, or III, or NAIA.
Team Criteria (meet at least one criterion)
- State Champion Team
- State Runner-Up Team
Coaching Criteria (meet at least one criterion)
- State Champs
- State Runner-Up
- State or National Hall of Fame
- Coach-of-the-Year by respective Iowa high school coaches association
The selection committee may override the above criteria if they feel the accomplishments/contributions are so outstanding as to deserve recognition.